This Writing Life: Does Plot = Character?

When learning about writing fiction, it usually isn’t long before a maxim something along the lines of ‘plot equals character’ turns up. The idea here, of course, is that the plot of any story is based on the actions of the characters, and that the two are therefore inseparable. Even if all your characters do is sit around and talk (à la ‘Waiting for Godot’, perhaps), that’s still a plot, and it’s your characters that have formed it.

I was thinking about this rule the other day though, and began to have my doubts. It certainly holds true for many genres – you’d have no plot at all in some romances without the interaction of the central two characters – but what about fantasy? If there’s any genre at all that can have plot without character, it’s got to be fantasy and SF, which has traditionally been very idea-heavy.

And, aha! I even came up with some examples. Take a natural disaster, for example, or the workings of a complex magical spell – both could create a plot without the intervention of characters. A volcano doesn’t wait for permission before it erupts, and perhaps that spell was the work of an individual long-dead. The events it triggers could occur without a character ever coming into view.

This, though, is where I ran into a wall. Yes, a volcano can erupt if there’s no-one around to see it, as could that spell – but then where’s the plot? Is there any, without characters? It’s what those characters do in response – how they escape the volcano, or negate the spell, or fall in love in the process – that really builds a story. Without them, you have instead a piece of natural history writing, or geology, or similar – even a historical treatise on that spell would likely mention the individual who created it.

In the end, then, the old maxim holds true, at least in every example I can think of. You simply can’t have a plot – a story – without characters and their choices. It’s no wonder, then, that in my recent work I’ve discovered I just can’t make progress if I don’t have defined characters before I begin – because, without them, there’s simply nothing to write about.

On a final note, a challenge: if you really can think of a plot without characters, please let me know! I haven’t managed to think of one yet, but I’m willing to bet they’re out there, and have just eluded me so far.

What I’m Working On, 2012 Edition

It’s been a while since I’ve mentioned any specifics about the writing projects I’m currently working on, so I thought I’d do that today, both for the curiosity of my readers and my own edification (sometimes, writing things down is the only way to get a clear look at them). So, get ready for ‘what my life is going to consist of for the next 18 months’ – and yes, I really do envisage this list will take that long to work through, if not longer.

  • The fantasy novella.     This is my most recently completed piece of work, and the only one written to a deadline. With both first draft and edits done, it’s now ready for a beta-reader (when I can get the .epub version to stop giving frustrating error messages), whatever last few tweaks I need to make and submission before the end of October. It also starts the running theme of this whole list: nothing I’ve written recently has a name!
  • The urban fantasy novella.     Urban fantasy is a genre I keep having at go at, then abandoning. My most recent project, though, comes from an idea that quite literally came to me in a dream, several years ago. I’m now 10k words into an estimated total of anything from 40-60k. My plan with this particular piece is to venture into the world of e-publishing, not by self-publishing, but by submitting to several small press e-publishers who pay good royalty rates and specialise in romance.
  • The completed-first-draft fantasy novel.     This is the novel I finished in the spring, and is set in the same world as that fantasy novella above. It’s 120k words, and both the longest and the fastest novel I’ve ever written. It’s also going to be a mammoth editing task, but I’m feeling more confident about that after using the same editing process on the novella. When it’s finished? This’ll probably be another ‘submit to agents and traditional publishers’ endeavour.
  • The just-started-the-first-draft fantasy novel.     I started another, unrelated fantasy just after I’d finished the first draft of that last one. This one stands at less than 10k words so far, but I’ve done a fair amount of world-building and planning, and I’m hoping to go back to it next year.
  • The nothing-but-notes modern fantasy novel.     This last project is one I’ve been thinking about, on and off, for perhaps a year. It’s a modern fantasy, set in the rural area I grew up in. It’s also nothing but a first scene, a bit of research and the occasional daydream, at the moment. It’s a novel I really, really want to write, but it’s also different to anything else I’ve ever attempted, so I’m content to sit on it for a while yet.

Looking at that list is making me feel rather exhausted! So, what are you working on at the moment, and have you got a ‘to do’ list as long  as mine – or does no-one else plan that far ahead?!

Growing Into Literary Fiction

There has always, for as long as I can remember, been a common theme to the books I gravitate towards (and the books I write) – that of fantasy, and to a lesser extent SF. The same can be said of my favourite films, and games, and even artwork. I always seem to gravitate towards works that have an element of the fantastic, as I wrote about here. Recently, though, I’ve noticed something else creeping into my standard reading fare: literary fiction.

I’ve always, in the past, been a bit leery of lit. fic. The most lauded books, classic and modern, seemed to have little or no relation to my life or my concerns. The same could be said of fantasy novels, but if those focused on middle-aged men or teenage boys, at least there was magic and dragons and strange new worlds to hold my attention. Lit. fic simply didn’t have the same appeal.

Recently though, epic fantasy began to lose a little of its shine for me. There have been some brilliant fantasies out in recent years, but I began to grow a bit weary of yet another vast uncharted world, or overly complicated magic system, or female character who couldn’t fall in love with just a normal bloke – it had to be a vampire/werewolf/farmboy-who-grows-up-to-be-prince. As an alternative, I began to look for something entirely different to read.

First, I turned to Haruki Murukami, then to Hilary Mantel. Both writers have, perhaps, more of ‘genre’ fiction in their work than your average lit. fic. writer (one verging on fantasy, the other having won the Booker prize for a historical novel about Thomas Cromwell), but they were still a step away from my usual reading material. I began to realise just how far I was drifting from traditional fantasy, though, when I brought home a library book which proudly proclaimed it had won the Pulitzer.

I don’t honestly know what’s made me turn towards these books, other than that they’re a change of pace. Perhaps this post’s titles is misleading, too – I don’t consider lit. fic. any more ‘grown up’ than fantasy, or any more worthy, no matter what prize judges might claim. I’m fairly certain I won’t suddenly write a book about an American college professor having an affair with a nubile young student, either – fantasy is still where my heart resides. Still, I’m taking my sudden shift in choice of books as a positive, for however long it lasts: it’s a way to broaden my horizons, improve my writing and, perhaps most importantly, never fall out of love with reading.

This Writing Life: The Standing Desk, Part the 1st

Apologies, first of all, for my extended absence from the blog. Real life got in the way for a while – a job interview (and yes, I got the job!), a holiday, family commitments, gaming, and of course, writing deadlines (extended another month. Phew) – but it’s back to normal now. Well, almost back to normal. You see, I’ve decided to make a bit of a change to my writing life, which means that my office desk now looks like this.

I’ve blogged in the past about the health problems I’ve developed through writing, or more specifically spending a lot of time at the computer. I’ve been dealing with RSI for several years now, and I’m always on the look out for new ways to alleviate it (without, of course, giving up writing), particularly since my aching hand and wrist were recently joined by stiffness in my neck and right shoulder.

I decided these new problems were at least partly caused by my monitor being too low, causing me to hunch up over my desk without even realising I was doing so. Rather than just raise my monitor, though, I decided to go a whole step further and set up a standing desk. Not wanting to buy a whole new desk though, I looked for an alternative, and my end result can be seen in the photo.

The first part involved raising my monitor, using one of these. Whilst the arm is a large, heavy, almost over-engineered piece of kit, it gives me the flexibility to keep my monitor at eye-level whether I’m standing up or sitting down. At the moment, the stands for my keyboard and mouse are actually the box and polystyrene packaging that the monitor arm came in, but I’ll replace these if this whole set-up is still to my liking in a few weeks’ time.

So, how is the standing desk working so far? I’ve only been using it for a couple of days, so it’s impossible to tell yet whether my RSI and muscle aches will improve. So far I’m still in the adjustment phase: it’s clear that writing standing up is going to take a bit of getting used to, both in terms of how initially tiring it is and how far my keyboard is from my line of sight.

In the long term though, I’m hoping for all manner of health benefits, and it seems many writers feel the same – using a standing desk seems to be an increasingly popular option. Only time will tell, though, whether I’m going to be joining their ranks for good.

It’s the Guild Wars 2 Screenshot Bonanza!

I’m working to a deadline on a novella at the moment, as well as preparing for a job interview this week, and my brain is pretty much fried. Add to that a week away from home and lately this blog hasn’t been getting the attention it deserves. As I’m still pressed for time, I thought I’d post a few more screenshots from the activity that’s eating most of my non-writing time: Guild Wars 2.

Just two weeks ago, the game finally saw it’s official release, after months of beta tests, and the landscapes within Tyria (the world of Guild Wars 2) remain as captivating as ever. If you’re a gamer, I hope you enjoy the pictures, and even if you’re not I think there’s plenty to admire – and perhaps to give you story ideas! – in the screenshots below.

Krytan Bridge

This Writing Life: For Love and Money

I think it’s fair to say that in the current ‘economic climate’ (as the media and politicians keep calling this great bottomless pit we’re staring into), there are plenty of people out there – myself included – who could do with a little more cash. Writing, at least of fiction, tends not to be a particularly profitable occupation, yet in times of hardship plenty of us – again, myself included – don’t put down our metaphorical pens. We’re doing this for the love.

It’s the idea of ‘for the love’ that is consistently bandied about in writing circles. It can be a frustrating thing to hear when it’s being spouted by a best-selling, millionaire author, but at the same time there’s a great deal of truth to it. The market moves quickly; the publishing industry is slow; writing a novel and subsequently selling it might take you ten weeks, or ten years. Even when you sell a novel, there’s no guarantee you’ll be able to live off the proceeds, which makes the idea of writing for money rather than love somewhat futile.

There’s the emotional side to it, too. Writing a novel is bloody hard work – writing something you hate because you think it’s going to make you money must be excruciating, especially if it then doesn’t sell. At least if you’ve spent ten years writing unsellable novels that you love, you won’t feel like you’ve wasted your time (or not quite as much, anyway).

And yet, there are a growing number of new writers who are convinced that, with the rise of e-publishing, they can make thousands selling ebooks. It’s true that some people can, and that it’s likely the majority of these books are being written, initially, for pleasure rather than economic reasons. Still, it doesn’t take a great deal of study of the publishing industry to know that most wannabe author superstars will never make more than a few hundred dollars, and some won’t even break even.

So, writing specifically for money is probably infeasible, whilst writing for love is worthwhile but will still leave you with bills to pay. It sounds like a hopeless situation – is there any possibility of love and money colliding?

Thankfully, I think there is. For a start, I’d bet that the vast majority of traditionally published fiction was written ‘for the love’, even if the author had a contract to fulfil. Loving your characters and the story you’re telling really shines through in a book, making your voice and your world come to life in a way that readers will both identify and appreciate. There are, too, an increasing number of non-traditional outlets for authors to sell their work, from the e-publishing arms of major enterprises to high quality self-publishing (some writers are making thousands on their own, remember).

We may be a way off salaries for writers, as China Miéville espouses, but I’m still hopeful. Be it with a traditional publisher or just selling ebooks on Amazon, there are and always will be ways for good writers to make money, whilst still writing books that they – and their readers – love through and through.

This Writing Life: Coasting

The last few weeks have been strange ones for me, writing-wise. I’ve been working consistently, but because I’ve been flitting between half a dozen different things (novel edits, research and first pages of another novel, a novella for an anthology etc. etc.), I don’t feel as if I’m getting anything done. As a result, I feel rather like I’m coasting along: not falling behind, not slacking off, but not really making progress either.

Even for an unpublished writer, I’ve discovered this is a life with an uneven schedule. You’ll be plugging away at a novel for months, only to feel bereft and directionless when it’s done. You’ll go from having no finished short stories and nothing to submit, to several done and needing submitting, in the space of a month – and when you do submit, you’ll hear nothing for weeks, before getting a flurry of responses. Interesting calls for submissions also seem to come in clusters, with a dearth of deadlines to work toward one month and three or four the next.

So, what to do in those periods when you feel to be coasting? It’s easy to just let the current drag you along – and that can be fine if you’re genuinely working, as I am – but sometimes you need to break free. Keep track of what you’re working on, how much you’ve accomplished, and what deadlines might suddenly loom up at you if you let them. You might find that you need to change tack and work on something else, or that you actually are on the right track (and if you are, congratulations! I never seem to be working on what I think I should be working on).

When coasting can, of course, be the right time to take a break, or to write something completely new, though of course that depends on what you’re abandoning to do so. You can easily feel as if you’re not making progress when right in the middle of a novel, but that’s one very good example of when not to pack it all in and do something else. Get the novel finished and then decide whether your work is taking the path you want it to – having that finished novel can make all the difference.

In my case, it’s a novella I’m currently plugging away at, and one which I started afresh this week (which is probably why I feel I have so little forward momentum). I can’t honestly tell at the moment whether this novella is going anywhere, or whether it’s going to be any good when it’s finished – I can only jump into that current and follow it downstream to the end, and start paddling harder as that deadline rushes towards me.

Walking in the Peak District

Where my partner and I live, we’re lucky enough to be more-or-less on the doorstep of the beautiful Peak District. We’ve been trying to get out there more this summer, to go walking and exploring, and I thought I’d share a few of the photos.

[For anyone who lives in the vicinity of the Peaks, we’ve found this a useful website for walks.]

These are some of the hills above Wolfscote Dale, which remind me of similar countryside in the Yorkshire Dales, where I grew up. You might be able to get an idea from this photo just how changeable the weather was on this particular walk – we had glorious sunshine and blue skies one minute, and got absolutely soaked the next!

Here we have a pool in the Haywood, which we crossed by stepping stones…

…and on the same, very varied, walk, this is the view from the top of Curbar Edge, on a pleasant but hazy morning. This part of the walk reminded me a great deal of the Roaches, which we visited only a few months ago, on an equally pleasant but much clearer day.

 

This Writing Life: Throwing Words Away

The Olympics are in their winding-down stages now, so I thought I’d take a break from my Not-Quite Cultural Olympiad (I had a couple more posts in mind, which I’ll get to if I have the chance next week). Instead, it’s back to writing, and something I’ve been thinking about his morning, namely throwing words away.

You see, I’m working on a novella, set in a world I’ve already written a novel about, but twenty years after those events.  All I have to go on for guidance is the world I’ve already created and a particular character (the novella is for a specific anthology, and this character is absolutely perfect for the anthology’s guidelines). I could, in theory and as long as my character stays in character, write about anything – which is turning out to be exactly the problem. I have too many choices, and none of them seem to be quite working.

And now we get to the heart of this post: I’ve written 5000 words on the novella this week, but this morning I decided the story just isn’t going as well as I’d like. Despite being up against a deadline, and with anything up to 40k words to write, I’m going to need to throw most of those initial 5k away.

I’m made similar decisions in the past, but this is the first time I’ve been fairly certain I’ll be unable to reuse any of what I’ve written so far. Instead, I’m looking at entirely different plots, which diverge so far from my ideas at the beginning of the week that that first 5k has become entirely meaningless. It’s a frustrating process, particularly with a deadline constraining just how much time I have to work on this novella.

Of course, I know that no writing is a waste of time. I’ve learnt more from this failure than from writing an opening I was perfectly happy with first time. Still, there’s something more annoying about throwing words away than there is about writing an entire story before deciding there’s no point editing it and putting it aside. In that instance, I can take the whole story as an educational exercise, which I can study once and then never look at again. This time round, despite throwing those words away, I’m not prepared to abandon the novella as a whole, and no matter what I’ve learnt, I can’t help but feeling I’ve been wasting time.

So, throwing words away: have you done it? And if you have, what’s the largest number of words you’ve discarded? My 5000 wasn’t too severe – I’m waiting for your horror stories!

My Not-Quite Cultural Olympiad: Poland

[Details of what my Not-Quite Cultural Olympiad is all about are here.]

For the fourth post in this series, we’re coming back to Europe, but venturing into yet another medium: video games. It’s fair to say that Poland might not be the country you’d immediately associate with game development, but that’s been changing over the last few years with the release of The Witcher and its sequel (which I’ve chosen a picture from below, because I like the artwork more), the aptly-named Witcher 2.

The games are based on a series of books and short stories (which I’ve yet to read, hence my focus on the games) by the Polish writer Andrzej Sapkowski, and were developed by the Polish company CD Projekt Red. The ‘witcher’ of the title is Geralt of Rivia, a mutant, an amnesiac and a monster hunter who, in the games at least, frequently gets involved in politics (despite his assertions of wanting to walk away, he never seems to quite manage it).

The gamer takes on the role of Geralt and is thrust into a world that’s both violent and beautiful, and tends to feel more believable than the settings of many fantasy RPGs (Elder Scrolls, I’m looking at you). Along the way, there’s a vast cast of characters to meet and interact with, and dozens of choices to make which affect the overall course of the game. Whilst it’s impossible, therefore, to experience every option in the storyline without playing the game more than once (the same holds true for both of the titles), these choices provide more structure than many RPGs, and give a sense almost of a choose-your-own-adventure novel, in which the player’s decisions genuinely affect the story’s outcome.

Admittedly, these aren’t perfect games. The first Witcher game, for example (which I’ve played in more depth, of the two) was frequently touted as being mature and thought-provoking, but occasionally tripped itself up with some groan-inducingly juvenile moments, particularly where Geralt’s ‘relationships’ are concerned. The plot, meanwhile, had plenty of nice touches and some strong dialogue in places, but floundered if the player didn’t complete events in the right order, or simply couldn’t work out what to do.

Still, these are impressive games, more ambitious and more intricately-plotted than many similar titles. Geralt himself is also a memorable character, no matter what path you as the gamer make him walk down – and even if many of those paths come to something of a sticky end! Despite my love of RPGs, there have been very few games that have genuinely made me care how they’re going to end, but the Witcher was one of them, and I have high hopes that the Witcher 2 will be the same.