This Writing Life: Ambition, Writer’s Block and Fear

Before I start, I want to direct your attention over here, to this excellent blog post about getting blocked in your writing, and how often that stems from fear. Next, I have to make a confession: recently, I’ve been feeling exactly as that posts describes. Every time I contemplate starting a new piece of work, I get struck by The Fear, and can’t make any progress.

You see, I have both a short story I want to write and another novel I want to start. Whenever I consider them though, I’m assailed by doubts and become ‘blocked’. What if the short story gets rejected by the editors of the anthology I’m specifically writing it for? What if I get the details wrong? (It’s historical fantasy, which makes this a more pertinent fear than ever.) What if the novel doesn’t live up to the great expectations I have for it? What if I can’t even finish it?

Yeah, my writing brain is a bit of a mess at the moment, as I shuffle between projects and try to work out what I actually want to be doing. Fear and doubt, of course, don’t make it any easier, even though I can answer all those questions easily. If the story is rejected, I’ll try to sell it elsewhere, or treat it as a learning exercise. If the details are wrong, I simply haven’t done enough research. The novel won’t live up my to my expectations – they never do – but that doesn’t mean it won’t be good. And I will finish it, if I plan it carefully enough to begin with.

Perhaps more importantly, I’ve been thinking about where this fear comes from. Partly it’s insecurity, which I don’t think any writer quite gets over, no matter how successful they are. Part of it, though, comes from ambition.

We should always be ambitious as writers, always striving to improve our work and try new things and potentially break new ground in our chosen genres. In being ambitious, though, there is always fear. If we did the same thing over and over again, we’d know exactly how to do it. Trying new things brings doubt, and the fear that we might fail abyssmally – but it also allows us to grow as writers, and ultimately improve. Then we can accomplish more things without fear, until we decide upon trying something new and go through all the doubts again…

It’s a never-ending cycle, or at least never-ending as long as we keep writing. Perhaps that’s no consolation, but I’m trying to look at it this way: the fear is there because I’m being ambitious, and as long as I keep feeling it, I know I’m pushing myself to write better and better.

This Writing Life: Resolution in Character Arcs – and Character Deaths

As I approach the end of the edits on my novel, I’ve been thinking about the ending itself and whether it does everything I want it to. An ending needs to do a number of important things, after all: it needs to resolve the plot and the remaining questions or mysteries (or perhaps leave one or two dangling for sequels); it needs to keep the reader’s attention, perhaps even more strongly than earlier parts of the book; and, most importantly of all I think, it needs to resolve the characters’ stories – their arcs.

I think – or at least I hope – I’ve achieved that for the characters in my novel, particularly the two from whose point-of-view the story is told. They’ve both changed during the course of the novel, and I’ve tried to reflect that at the end. It’s this sort of resolution – even more than the defeat of the villain – that I find most satisfying in stories, which is why I’ve tried so hard to achieve it.

In thinking about character arcs, I’m also reminded of examples that did exactly the opposite of what I’ve tried to do – with frustrating results. Just a few months ago, the BBC aired the very last series of Spooks, a drama that had been running for years. I watched the last series, as I’d watched all the others, and enjoyed it. Right up until the end of the very last episode, that is. [Major spoilers ahead, in case you hadn’t guessed. If you haven’t watched the end of Spooks and want it to remain a mystery, stop reading now.]

You see, there were two major characters in the series – Harry and Ruth – who had been having an on-off almost-relationship for years (literally years, if you’d watched the multiple series when they were first shown on TV). As the last series came to an end, and secret after secret was uncovered, there seemed to me three ways in which the Ruth-Harry relationship could be resolved.

The first was for them to end up together, and do the equivalent of riding off into the sunset. Whilst it wouldn’t be quite that simple – both had been deeply scarred by their work for MI5 – I was certain that wouldn’t be the way the series ended. Spooks had always been ruthless with its characters, and shown no qualms about killing them off. I didn’t really expect that to change.

So, that left two more options. I was hoping they would go with the following: Harry would be killed, whilst Ruth – who had been preparing to retire to the seaside and start a new life – would do just that. Here, I thought, would be resolution. Harry, whose secrets were all finally revealed in the last episode, would at least find more peace than he’d ever had in his working life. Ruth would finally get the fresh start she’d been craving. It wouldn’t be a happy ending, but it would resolve both character arcs in what I would consider a satisfying manner.

Instead, we got just the opposite. It was Ruth who was killed, and Harry who lived, effectively providing no resolution to their character arcs at all. Everything Ruth had been hoping and planning for was wiped out by her death. Harry, now even more broken than before, didn’t even leave MI5 – he briefly mourned Ruth, then just went back to work.

I was deeply frustrated with this ending to a series I had been watching for years. I felt like all my hopes for the characters were completely obliterated, and their arcs were incomplete; Harry’s in particular was left in a kind of depressing limbo. I almost wished I hadn’t watched the final series at all, as everything that had happened previously was made completely in vain by the choice of ending.

Clearly, not all stories have to have a happy ending. Many are better without one. However, if your novel leaves your character arcs as unravelled as Spooks did, there’s a big risk that your reader will end up feeling alienated and frustrated. In the case of Spooks, that was no problem for the BBC, but if you’re trying to build a fanbase as a writer, that could be disastrous. Why pick up another of an author’s books if you fear their characters are going to be left abandoned at the end? It’s when characters don’t feel to have gone through a story in vain, whether they live or die at the end, that I’m more tempted to read the next book in the series.

So, what endings have you read or watched that have been either deeply satisfying, or deeply frustrating – and why?

This Writing Life: The Stories You Need To Write

In the last couple of years, I’ve worked on a number of novels and many more short stories. Although the process for each can be very different – and no two novels get completed in the same way either – it would be sensible to suppose that my end goal for them all would be the same. That goal would, of course, be publication, if you haven’t already guessed. However, out of the four novels I’ve worked on in the past 18 months, there’s only a single one that I’m going to send out to agents.

The more projects I work on, the more I realise that my stories typically fall into three categories. The first: those I want to get published. These are the ones I work on the longest, edit the most exhaustively and get beta-read. The second category, therefore, is fairly obvious: stories that are unpublishable. A fair chunk of what I start never gets finished, either because it doesn’t go to plan or I decide my initial idea really wasn’t as good as I thought. Even when I do finish these stories, sometimes I decide they’re just not good enough to send out into the world, and that it would be better to sit on them (and maybe rewrite them later).

There is a third category, though, which is what this post is really about: stories that are unpublishable, but that you need to write – and finish – anyway. I think a good chunk of the fiction produced by a beginning writer will fall into this category, my own work included. These are practice stories, shorts to test out world-building for later novels, experiments in tone and style. These are the stories that frequently turn out utterly unreadable, but were absolutely necessary to improve your writing skills.

For me, this category is not just made up of short stories, either. I’ve written any number of novels that I’d also include, which were experiments in everything from first-person POV to writing longer chapters. It’s possible that I’ll rewrite these novels some day, but given the number of new ideas I have on a daily basis, it’s unlikely. The important thing, though, is that these novels were necessary for me to write; instead of rewriting them, I’ll go off and write newer, better novels in first-person POV or with longer chapters, using what I’ve learned the first time round. I haven’t been wasting my time writing unpublishable fiction: I’ve been learning, and strengthening my writing skills, and getting to the point (hopefully) where more of my stories are of publishable quality than not.

So, the next time you start writing a new, unplanned novel in the middle of the night, or decide to write fan-fiction, or a story from the POV of a snail, remember that you’re not wasting your time, no matter how unpublishable the story might be. Instead, you’re practising your craft, and writing the stories you need to write to make you a better writer in the long run.

This Writing Life: The Compulsion to Write

A couple of things inspired this post, the first being, of course, the madness that is NaNoWriMo and the vast swathe of words that finishing it requires. The other bit of inspiration comes from something said to me a couple of weeks ago. One of my co-workers is an artist and photographer. “I once tried to see how long I could go without creating art,” he said (I’m paraphrasing here, but the gist is right). “I got to about a month, then had to create something because I felt like I was going mad.”

Art, it seems, is very much a compulsion, be that drawing or music, dance or writing. Having a break from writing can be pleasant, of course. Not writing for any great length of time – be it because of other commitments, or lack of inspiration, or illness – is decidedly less so. During my first year at uni, I went through six months without writing more than a few thousand words of fiction. Whilst I was kept busy writing essays and other things, the lack of fiction writing in my life wasn’t something I was happy about.

Now, I certainly wouldn’t say my writing compulsion goes as far as hypergraphia, but it’s still there all the same, and I would think it’s there in most writers, to a greater or lesser extent. Writing, as was mentioned in the comments thread a couple of posts ago, is not something you do for fame and money (in most cases, anyway). It’s something we do because we have to; because the world seems a little bit duller and a little bit colder when we’re not writing.

Which, appropriately, brings me back to NaNoWriMo. There are many great reasons to take part: being surrounded, physically or in online communities, by other people who understand that urge to write is just one of them. It’s the main reason I’ve been blogging exclusively about writing throughout November. When you discover you have that compulsion to write, and try to make it a part of your life, you quickly discover just how little everyone around you (family, friends, even spouses) understands it. NaNoWriMo, though, does a great job of bringing writers together, and reminding us that there are plenty of people out there who understand our passion – and not just understand it either, but celebrate it.

(On a final note, we’re now three weeks into NaNoWriMo! If you’re still hanging in there, whether you’re behind – like me – or not, keep up the good work. The end is in sight!)

NaNoWriMo: Day 18 – Falling Behind

I was, until about halfway through NaNoWriMo, completely on track. And then, of course, this week came along and hit me right between the eyes. Non-writing-related deadlines. Visits from family. Building work taking place in the living room. Just like three buses coming along at once, every delay decided to show up at the same time.

I now haven’t written anything on my novel for about three days. I suspect I’m somewhere in the region of 5-6k words behind. Admittedly, that’s not too much, but it’ll quickly mount up if I don’t get back to writing soon. Luckily, I should be able to do that this afternoon, and this weekend. I have, more or less, cleared the decks so that the last week of November can encompass writing and nothing else.

As ever, after a few days away, I’m really looking forward to getting back to work. At the same time, I’m looking forward to December and a chance for a rest (both from writing, and in the form of an actual holiday). Not that I’ll actually be able to go right through December without writing, but still…

So, how are everyone’s novels coming along, NaNo novels or otherwise? I need to see some big word counts and forward progress to inspire me to the same heights this weekend!

This Writing Life: Peaks and Troughs

I’m well into the middle of NaNoWriMo now, with nearly 24k words written. Writing so much in such a short space of time (two weeks, to be exact) seems to have thrown every aspect of first-draft novel writing at me very quickly. It’s my usual writing process, compressed into a really short space of time. As such, I’ve been reminded how many peaks and troughs there are in writing. These seem to come in two forms: in the story itself, and in the writer’s enthusiasm for it.

The first should, in general, be intentional. You can’t write a novel entirely consisting of action scenes (although someone’s probably going to tell me this one’s been done…), or emotional, teary arguments between characters. Whilst conflict is the lifeblood of most novels, there have to be peaks and troughs in that conflict, at least until the final climax/show-down/boss battle or whatever you want to call it. Particularly if you’re writing a long book (like an epic fantasy), there need to be chances between the action scenes for readers to get to know your characters in their quieter moments, or to introduce interesting bits of world-building.

Those second peaks seem to map frequently, but not exclusively, onto the first. When you’re deep in action or scenes where everything is falling apart for your characters, the words tend to flow. Action! Conflict! Your main character finding out he’s fathered a love-child with his best friend’s wife! These exciting moments can be as much fun to write as they are to read. It’s the in-between moments that are often more difficult. Yes, you need to get across some key piece of world-building, and your characters desperately need a break if they’re not going to die from exhaustion, but how to make that interesting for the reader? How to make it interesting enough for yourself that you want to write it in the first place?

I think the key is not to let these scenes get too long (unless they need to be – there’s a reason to break every rule). Have your characters been sitting in the pub for the last three pages? Can you no longer bear to open your Word document? Time to throw in some more action (and if you can’t think of anything, try looking at NaNoWriMo’s novel dares). Ninjas! Zombies! The love-children of ninja zombies (ew…)!

So, if your NaNoWriMo novel is floundering, it might be time to break your characters – and yourself – out of the trough and climb back to the giddy peaks of action, excitement, and perhaps anything else a NaNo dare throws at you.

This Writing Life: Why I’m Doing NaNoWriMo 2011

Every year, when November looms, I consider whether to take part in NaNoWriMo. Last year, I even wrote a post about why I wasn’t going to join in, so this year I thought I’d post in the other direction.

There are always a few questions I ask myself over NaNoWriMo. Do I have anything I want to write? Do I have time? Is it going to be any benefit to me? The first two are quite easy to answer: I do have time, and I do have a novel in mind that will work perfectly for NaNoWriMo. The third question is more complicated, but it’s also the most important one.

When I first finished NaNoWriMo, back in 2007, I hadn’t properly written for over a year. I was desperate to get back to writing, and needed a big push to help me on my way. NaNo provided exactly that, and I’ve kept pretty good writing habits ever since then. Last year, I wrote somewhere in the region of 160k words, and the total may well be higher this year. That doesn’t include the vast amount of editing I’ve done on a recent novel, either, or these blog posts.

However, 160k words in a year isn’t that much for many professional writers. When I’m working on a novel, I aim for 1000 words a day, which again isn’t very much (and certainly isn’t very ambitious given the amount of time in my day I can devote to writing). This year’s NaNo, then, will be a chance to up my daily word count, hopefully to a level I can sustain next year, and continue to improve upon.

Aside from word counts, I’m hoping this year’s NaNoWriMo will provide a big boost to my creativity and my self-motivation. This year has been hard for me: the harder I’ve tried to work, the less I’ve felt to accomplish. It’s a frustrating feeling. Writing an entire children’s novel in the space of November would go a long way towards helping me feel that I’ve actually achieved something this year, which will hopefully carry me through into 2012 (for which I have big plans, as ever).

So, if you’re taking part in NaNoWriMo this year, let me know in the comments. Why are you taking part? Do you want to prove something to yourself, or write a novel for the first time? Or do you just enjoy a challenge, and all the craziness that ensues on the NaNoWriMo forums throughout November?

This Writing Life: Naming Characters – Some Useful Links

As I’ve been starting a number of new short stories, I’ve been thinking a great deal recently about character names – how to choose them, where to find them, whether they’re suitable for a particular setting or character. I don’t usually have a lot of trouble choosing character names, at least not for minor characters, but there are always a handful that just refuse to be named. Or whose names change halfway through a story. Or who arrive in my head fully formed, name intact, but that name happens to be wildly inappropriate.

I’m hoping to write another post later about how to choose names and what things to look for when naming characters. To begin with though, I wanted to share a few useful links regarding where to find your characters’ names. These are sites that I’ve used myself, and which have been useful to me time and again, so I hope they’ll be useful to you too.

Baby name sites: This is a fairly obvious one, but there are huge numbers of these sites available, some more useful than others (there are also many baby name books out there, but I’m sticking with websites for this post). My favourite tends to be this one. There are a lot of really useful features on this particular site: you can search for a name by its meaning, or by which letters it starts with, or by where it originates. You might first think of using the name ‘Sarah’, for example, but feel it’s not quite right. Maybe a different name that starts with the name syllable, like Sarafina, or Sarita (both taken from the first page of a quick search, and which are Latin and Hebrew respectively) might work better.

Kate Monk’s Onomastikon: Originally developed for role-players, this dictionary of names is one of the most useful lists I’ve come across. It includes names from around the world, ordered by their origin. Need a Japanese name, or a Viking one, or a Swahili one? This is the site to head for.

Google and Wikipedia: Ok, these might be even more obvious than baby name sites, but they’re ones you need to remember to use. Once you’ve come up with a name, stick it into Google (or your search engine of choice) and see what comes up. If the only sites returned are obscure Chinese technology companies or random Facebook pages, you’re probably fine to use that name. If you think you’ve just invented the name ‘Frodo’ though, and are convinced that it can’t possibly have any other connotations than your own work… Well, this is where Google will save you from making an idiot of yourself.

If you have any more useful links, feel free to share them in the comments (although bear in mind that I may have to pull comments with links out of the moderation queue). I’d love to put together a more comprehensive list, and discover more sites to make naming those recalcitrant characters a little bit easier.

This Writing Life: The Horrifying Realisation of Too Few Words

I’ve been debating for a week now whether I really wanted to talk about this on the blog, but ultimately I decided that my pain might be useful for other writers out there, so here we are. You see, last week, whilst I was busily preparing to submit my novel to agents, I came to a horrifying realisation. This novel, that I’ve considered ‘finished’ for weeks, that I’ve been working on for a good couple of years… It’s too short. Far too short. Potentially 40k words too short.

I always write short first drafts. My earliest novels never passed 70k words. This one came to about 80k, and passed 90k after my first round of edits. I told myself that was long enough – and it is, for many genres, but for traditional fantasy (not urban), it’s a bit on the low side. Even so, I pressed on. With the second round of edits complete, and the book ready to query, it had shrunk to 85k words. Still, I told myself I’d included everything I needed to in the novel. It was long enough.

And then I came across a forum thread – a discussion with an agent – in which novel length was being discussed. This agent suggested that, even at the low end, fantasy novels tend to be around 120k words. Another writer, who’s just sold a book and who went through the same novel revision course I did, mentioned adding 20k words to her 100k manuscript. And here I was, about to submit to this agent, with an 85k word novel.

I won’t go into all the thoughts that went through my head during the few hours that followed (although they ranged from ‘I’m sure they’ll make an exception for my novel’ to ‘I should just scrap this and move on to something else’). In the end, I realised I was just going to have to make the damn thing longer. Which is what I’m working on now.

My most recent first draft is on hold (thankfully I’d just reached a very convenient stopping point) while I go back to my ‘finished’ novel and add somewhere between 20k and 40k new words. New scenes. New characters. Whole new subplots. It’ll be a stronger novel by the time I’ve finished – I’ll have room to flesh out all those events and conflicts I skipped past before because I thought I didn’t have room for them in this book – but I’ve got a hell of a lot of work ahead of me to reach that point. As ever though, it’s knowing that this will make the book better that keeps me going.

This Writing Life: Because Nobody Told Me I Couldn’t

When you’re learning to write, there feels to be a constant bombardment of rules. It’s not just submission guidelines (though those are a pain in the arse all their own) – it’s rules like ‘stick to the three-act structure’, ‘make sure your hero is sympathetic’, ‘don’t let style get in the way of story’. These rules always seem bandied about most frequently in the world of genre fiction. We’re constantly told that ‘different’ doesn’t sell.

Now, I’m not saying that these rules aren’t there for a good reason. Hanging your story around the three-act structure is a good, easy way of improving pacing. An unsympathetic hero will turn many readers off. I even wrote about keeping your style simple in my last Writing Life post. There are times though, when I simply don’t stop to consider the rules. Times when I do something that’s probably stupid, and knowing that I do it anyway – because nobody told me I couldn’t.

Thus, for example, my current novel has siv POV characters, a strange, meandering three part (but not really three act) structure and is about – of all things – Domesday Book. Sort of. Looking at that, it reads like the most ridiculous piece of writing I’ve ever attempted. It probably is. It’ll probably never sell, either. But at the same time, I’m both enjoying it immensely, and I’ve learned a great deal in writing it.

The best way to improve your writing is to write, pure and simple. As unpublished writers, we have a freedom unlike any other: we can write anything. Sometimes, it’s ignoring the rules, and doing stupid things just because nobody pointed out they were a bad idea, that produces the best results. And if the results are terrible after all? Well, you’ve probably just learned more than any number of three-act short stories could ever teach you.