This Writing Life: Finding the Middle of Your Story

I think I’ve written before about how I usually know the ending of a story before I start writing it. There are exceptions (there are ALWAYS exceptions in this game), but that’s my general rule. Usually, I come up with the ending, come up with the beginning (or vice versa), and then start writing, always heading as much towards that planned ending as I can. For my last couple of novels, it’s worked remarkably well. Having something to write towards is a great motivator. It also means that you don’t keep writing indefinitely, because you know when you’ve reached THE END.

For the last couple of weeks though, I’ve been dealing with a slightly different problem. I’ve been working on a short story, set in a world that I’d like to write a novel in this year. I wrote the beginning. The next scene, which followed on chronologically, was the end. In the middle, I wanted to show what was effectively in the past, and what led up to that beginning and end. ‘Wanted to’, is the key phrase here. I just couldn’t do it.

I frequently struggle with short story plots, more so than with novels. It can take me days, or even weeks, to work out what’s going to happen. I think part of the problem is that short stories are constrained to just a few thousand words. Every scene, every line, every word has to be doing something useful. And, of course, I always feel the need to get the structure of my stories right first time. I spend hours working out what’s going to happen, right down to details of what’s going to be revealed in each scene (which is something I approach much more organically when I’m writing a novel; things turn up in scenes, at least in the first draft, because it feels appropriate at the time and not down to prior planning).

I have, finally, worked out what’s going on in this current story. My initial scenes were of a man fleeing across the countryside and finally being caught. I needed to answer all sorts of questions: most crucially, why was he fleeing in the first place? How did I answer these questions and come up with the much-needed plot? Trial and error, mostly. Once I’d worked out what I needed to be asking myself (and I realise I’ve talked a lot about questions lately, but once again I’ve proved just how useful they are), I simply made list after list of potential answers. Then I picked the answer I liked best… and went on to the next question.

Middles are tricky things. In novels it’s often ploughing through them that’s the issue. In short stories, for me at least, it’s simply working out what happens next. And, as usual, this time I’ve found that middle through questions, trial and error, and sheer, bloody-minded hard work. One day I may find an easier way… but where’s the fun in that?!

This Writing Life: World-building and Character Questions

After my post yesterday about the power of asking ‘why?’ and ‘what if’ when developing a story, I wanted to share a couple of links to similarly useful questions (and ones that I’m going to be using when it comes time to plan my next novel). Both go into far more detail than those first two simple questions, giving long lists that you can use to strengthen your character development and world-building.

The first relates to characters and is by Anita Riggio, giving 45 questions to ask about fictional people to form a better picture of their backgrounds and personalities. Some of the questions won’t be relevant to every character; asking what their favourite movie is when you’re writing 12th century historical fiction isn’t going to get you very far, for example (although in that case, perhaps asking what your character’s favourite movie would be if they lived in the modern day might be interesting). However, there are also a number of useful questions about flaws, identity, regrets and obsessions that can be useful in really digging into the deepest parts of your characters’ psyches, making them far more real on the page.

The second is a set of world-building questions from Patricia C. Wrede, and if you thought the character ones were detailed, you ain’t seen nothing yet! There must be several hundred questions here, all geared towards creating a detailed and immersive fantasy/SF world. Whether or not you choose to answer every single one to build your fantasy setting, flicking through the list will throw up plenty of possibilities you may never have imagined before. Even if your story is set in a single city or village, have you considered how its citizens greet one another, or how climate affects what crops they can grow, or whether they allow representation of the human form in artwork? It can be seemingly minor details like these which advance your setting from cardboard backdrop to living, breathing world that is clearly functioning all the time, no matter what your characters are up to.

Neither set of questions is the definitive guide to developing either characters or a world (although the second certainly comes close), but both will make your story richer and help you create something that will live beyond the page in your readers’ memories.

This Writing Life: ‘What Ifs’ and ‘Whys’

There is a simple question that can often be asked to help make developing a world and story easier, particularly in the writing and planning of SF and fantasy novels. What if…? This is clearly important in the realms of alt. history: ‘what if the western Roman Empire never fell?’ ‘What if Europeans had never ventured to America?’ ‘What if Genghis Khan had conquered Europe?’ In other areas of the genre, ‘what ifs’ can be just as important, and might form the basis of any number of stories. ‘What if vampires were real and living among us?’ ‘What if aliens came to Earth with the intention of making humanity a race of slaves for their intergalactic building projects?’

Now, these are fairly obvious ‘what ifs’, so it’s fair to say that you can begin to develop much more interesting stories with more nuanced questions. You can also ask similar questions about characters: ‘What if a child is brought up to be a soldier, only to have the war end and leave them trying to make their way in a peaceful world?’ From that single ‘what if’, you can build a whole raft of different questions (‘What would that child be like as an adult and how would they relate to their new world?’) and, more crucially, the answers to them.

As well as the whats and the hows though, I think there’s a question that can be just as important to ask, and one which can make your story far deeper: why? ‘Why would those aliens choose Earth?’ ‘Why were children being trained to fight in a war at all?’ Asking why things are happening in your story – both why events have unfolded in a certain way and why your characters are acting the way they are – allows you to get a different perspective on your writing. When plots and characters arrive fully-formed from your subconscious, it’s asking ‘why?’ that helps make them clearer and stronger, both for yourself and your readers.

There are any number of questions you can ask in writing fiction, and I think ‘what if’ and ‘why’ are two of the most important. Of course, you’ve got to make sure you answer them too, or face a whole barrage of angry readers… But’s that an entirely different blog post!

This Writing Life: The Year AFTER the Novel

There is a feeling amongst a lot of unpublished writers that the holy grail of writing is the novel. So many people want to write a novel, or start one and never finish, that to actually get to the end of one feels like having ‘made it’. Writing 100,000 words (or however many your novel comes to) is such a massive achievement that it seems as if everything afterwards should be easy. A few light edits, dash off a query letter, grab an agent and hey presto! you’ve sold a book.

Sadly, it’s not that easy.

My partner made a comment a few days ago about my editing. “It’s a whole extra year of work after you’ve written the novel, isn’t it?” he said, and he’s right. By the time I reach the end of these edits (and the end is finally in sight now), a whole year will have passed since I started them. Longer, by far, than the amount of time it took me to write the first draft.

There are a few reasons for this. A lack of motivation, particularly in the second half of last year. Trying to work on too many things at once and not giving my edits the attention they needed. A lack of practice at editing in general, because I so frequently write first drafts which I never go back to. All in all, it’s not surprising it’s taken this long.

Today then, I want to put out something of a warning, or at least a note of caution. Writing a novel IS hard work, definitely. Unfortunately though, just reaching THE END is not enough, at least not for most people (and most new writers, in particular). When you’re considering how long working on your novel is going to take, you may need to double your first draft writing time to take editing into account – or even triple it if you already know you’re going to struggle. It’s only AFTER the editing that you can really say you’re finished, and start looking for agents or publishers.

I don’t want to diminish the achievement of writing a novel here, not at all. However, if you are coming to the end of one, it’s vital to be aware that the work isn’t over yet – and it might not be for some time.

This Writing Life: Dealing With Too Much Writing Time

In my last post, I talked about making a routine out of limited time, and the need to get that to work before pushing yourself to write in every spare moment. Today though, I want to talk about the opposite problem: having too much writing time.

This seems entirely counter-intuitive. The classic dream of the amateur writer (and a great number of professional writers) is to be able to make enough money to give up their day-job. To be able to spend all day writing, not cram three hundred words into their commute and the half hour before going to bed. It sounds utterly idyllic and, having done it (whilst unemployed and skint, which made it a bit less idyllic), it is.

There’s a problem though, particularly for people who suddenly find themselves thrust into the full-time writing life, usually having left their job either intentionally or through redundancy. Having all day, every day stretching before you sounds wonderful, but it’s actually incredibly overwhelming. Two feelings war with each other. There’s the complete lack of deadlines and pressure (at least if you’re unpublished), which gives you the feeling of freedom, but in reality means you end up playing computer games or watching TV. There’s also, conversely, a self-imposed pressure, telling you that you must make this work, which can be utterly paralysing. So paralysing, in fact, that you’re too scared of failure to even begin working.

I’ve been through both of these feelings. In fact, they’re things I deal with nearly every day, and certainly every week. Both can be exhausting (strangely, there’s nothing more tiring than a day of having absolutely nothing to do) and both prevent you from actually getting work done. At which point you feel like a failure and wonder why you’re bothering, which again prevents you from working. This turns into something a downward spiral; it’s no wonder that depression is so common amongst writers.

Rather than end on this negative note, I’m going to give a few tips that have worked for me, for dealing with having more time than you know what to do with.

  • Think small. Don’t keep fretting over how much of your novel is left to write, or how many long, empty months it will be before you’ll be ready to submit to agents. Instead, focus on writing a certain number of words a day, or editing a certain number of pages. Meeting these small goals gives a powerful sense of achievement, which in turn makes it easier to get to work the next day.
  • Find a support network. This might be friends or family (the fact that my partner asks me every evening what I’ve been doing during the day is a powerful motivator to actually do some work to tell him about). It could be a writing group. It could be an online group. I’ve even found that the simple act of listening to writing podcasts and reading writing blogs gives me a sense that I’m part of a wider community, filled with people who are going through exactly what I’m going through.
  • Think positive. This is probably the most important point of all. Yes, you can put pressure on yourself to meet goals and work hard. It’s good to do so. But if you’ve been working solidly for three weeks and all you want to do today is read a book and eat ice cream, then do it. The less stressed you are and the more you’re enjoying your working life, the easier it’ll be to keep writing.

The fact that this blog post is longer than most of the ones I write has shown me just how important a topic this is to me, and it’s one that I may revist in the future. For now though, what are your tips for and experiences of having writing as your main commitment?

This Writing Life: Make the Most of Your Routine

There is a particular piece of writing advice that I’ve seen espoused by a number of writers that goes like this: to make it as a professional writer, you have to be able to write at any time, anywhere, no matter what your schedule is like. This is a good piece of advice, particularly if you’ve got a hectic life. Those few hundred words you get in before breakfast or on your lunch break can add up to a novel faster than you’d imagine.

It’s not that type of write-whenever-you-can sort of writing that I want to talk about today, though. I think, for many writers, getting into a writing routine can be just as important. And it”s not just writing at the same time every day or every week that I’m talking about – more specifically, it’s knowing which parts of the rest of your life are quiet enough to allow for writing time, and then working out how to make that time routine.

Whether this is something you can accomodate will depend on your life. If you’ve got a full-time job, kids, a college course and volunteer work to fit in (for example), then your writing may well be restricted to a few minutes at a time, whenever you can manage it. But what if you know you’ve always got Wednesday evenings and Sunday mornings free? Or what if you know you could have those times free if you stayed up an hour longer on Wednesday and got up an hour earlier on Sunday?

This is what I mean when I suggest making the most of your routine. If you do have a routine – and I would imagine most people do – you need to work out how to fit your writing into it. Once your writing is actually part of your routine, and you wouldn’t miss it any more than you wouldn’t turn up to your day-job because you ‘didn’t feel like it’, that’s when you need to start filling in all those small, spare moments with writing too.

And, if you’re like me and you’re actually able to set aside quite a lot of time for writing, that novel or short story will be finished before you know it. (Although what you do when you’ve got too much time is an entirely different problem, which I’ll tackle in another post.)

This Writing Life: Perseverance and Making Your Own Luck

I’ve been thinking this morning about how much of life is about perseverance. There are very few things worth having that don’t require persistence and hard work to achieve or possess. Writing is just one of these things: you’re never going to sell your work if you don’t keep writing, keeping improving, keep submitting. Perseverance is only one part of selling fiction though – luck also comes into it. Having the right editor read the right piece of your work on the right day, when the stars are aligned and with a good wind behind you… Well, something like that anyway.

Luck is not something the writer has a lot of control over. You can’t guarantee that the editor you’ve submitted to isn’t going to read your manuscript on a day when she’s got flu and her cat’s just been sick in her favourite shoes – right before she puts her foot in them – or that said editor isn’t just going to throw out everything she looks at that day because she’s in a really bad mood because of the cat and the shoes and the flu.

This sounds pretty grim, for the budding writer. When so much is down to luck, there’s every chance that you’ll never get published. Right? Well, not entirely. This where the perseverance comes in, because perseverance is how you make your own luck. By continuing to work hard, and improve your writing, and keep submitting, you’re drastically improving your chances of getting published. Eventually, you might get to the point where your story is the one that snaps that editor out of her bad day, which makes her sit up with a grin and say, “I have to buy this!”

Perseverance is not an easy thing to cultivate, but like I said before, all good things in life take hard work. It’s the best way to improve your luck in the publishing industry, and certainly the only way to keep that luck consistent (plying an editor with drink might persuade them to buy one story, but if your writing isn’t up to scratch, they’ll never buy another).

This is the point, of course, where I have to make sure I’m taking my own advice. Am I really, truly persevering? There are certainly stories that I’ve given up on too quickly, both in terms of finishing them and continuing to submit them. Overall though, I think I’ve been doing pretty well with the persistence thing, which is why I’m hoping 2011 will be the year my luck changes for the better.

This Writing Life: Doing What Scares You

I’ve been thinking today about fear, particularly as it relates to writing, because I’m finding myself facing it in two different ways. First off, it’s finally got to the point where I have to start cutting and rewriting the novel I’m editing. For months, I’ve been making notes and deciding what needs to be changed, but the process of actually making those changes is much scarier. The second fear is one of finishing a handful of short stories, but not because I’m scared of the editing process this time. Instead, it’s the fact that, once I finally say “This is done,” there’s nothing to stop me submitting those stories for potential publication – and, of course, potential rejection.

How I’m going to work through this fear isn’t something I’ve entirely cracked yet. I will, I suppose, just keep working, doing a little bit at a time until actually reaching the end creeps up on me in an unassuming and non-scary manner. It’s the why I’m doing it I know far more clearly. You see, it many ways it would be much easier for me to start something new: to do some research and start a new novel, for example. No mean feat, of course, but it’s still easier, because I’d be a long way from the finishing line. The hard slog of writing a novel doesn’t scare me any more. Deciding I have to stop tinkering with something because it’s done, on the other hand…

As with all things in life though, it’s doing what scares you that’s really necessary. If I keep writing first drafts but never editing them, let along submitting them, I’ll spend the rest of my life writing solely for myself and never getting published. That’s not something I want to do, and I’m going to have to face my fears to avoid it.

There’s a saying that you should ‘do something every day that scares you’, which for a long time I thought was a load of rubbish. The more I think about it though, the more it makes sense. You don’t have to go sky-diving or swim with sharks every day to experience fear, because it’s doing much smaller scary things that will make the biggest difference to your life. In my case, that’s going to be editing this novel and submitting a few short stories. Scary, yes, but I think I’ll feel a lot better when I’ve done them – until the next scary thing comes along.

This Writing Life: My Discovery Writing Experiment

As I talked about in my last post, this week I finished the first draft of a novel. In that post, I also alluded to something that I want to talk about in more detail: my experiment in writing a novel without an outline.

Now, this wasn’t something I set out to do in the beginning. Before I started the novel, I had dutifully begun making notes and formulating the start of the plot. Somewhere in the midst of all that though, I decided to just start writing. What I ended up having was a middle and an idea for an end, but little clear idea of anything that would happen in the middle. I generally planned just one or two scenes ahead, deciding what would happen next based purely on how the previous scenes turned out when written.

In one way, this was clearly a success: I finished the novel. I’ll freely admit that I frequently struggled though, both to keep myself motivated (having no major set-pieces or exciting scenes that I was writing toward made getting through the middle of the book hard work) and to decide what would happen next. This latter was confounded by the sheer number of characters and plot strands I’d saddled myself with. Deciding which one to return to at any one time was mostly arbitrary and several of them petered out before the end of the book (or suddenly reemerged at the end, after having last appeared in the first 30k words).

However, I’ve come to the conclusion that using discovery writing wasn’t the reason that I struggled. In fact, for the first-person POV that I was writing, it worked very well. The problem was my lack of planning before I started writing. My world was hazy and, more importantly, so were my characters’ motivations. That second point was my real problem, as it was difficult to know what to write next when I didn’t know what my characters wanted.

Will I use discovery writing again? Probably, because every book demands to be written in a different way. However, next time I’ll make sure to have done a lot more background planning and world-building first, to ease the story along its way.

This Writing Life: Taking Multi-Tasking Too Far

Every time I do another update post on this blog, I’m reminded how many things I’m juggling. The first draft of one novel, an editing course to finish another, occasional short stories and now a proofreading course. Plus the job that actually pays the bills. For weeks now I’ve been sure I was coping, finding time to fit everything in and keep on top of it all. No more.

I wrote last time about illness and how I’ve been suffering a bit. It’s at times like these, when the everyday routine gets disrupted, that I realise just how much I’ve taken on. Suddenly, trying to fit everything in without exhausting myself becomes an impossible feat. I also find that I can only really concentrate on one thing at once. My normal thought patterns are fragmented and writing 1000 words is enough to leave me fried for the rest of the day.

Clearly this will change when I’m well again. I’ll go back to being able to multi-task and having the energy to do two or three things in a day. However, I’m starting to wonder if that’s a good thing. Time and again, I’ve read advice from seasoned writers telling us novices – and indeed other seasoned writers – to stick to one project at once. Finish one, they say, before you move on to something else. I’ve tended to ignore this advice, telling myself that I’m coping fine with the multi-tasking, but this brief illness has made me wonder if I was wrong.

My plan, therefore, is for something of an experiment. I’m going to use my same periods of work in the morning and early afternoon, but instead of working on something different in each (or even two things in the morning and a third in the afternoon, as is sometimes the case), I’m going to devote each day to one thing at once. A day of proofreading. A day of writing. A day of editing.

In reality, things will probably work out slightly differently. I’ll probably end up doing a full morning of editing or proofreading, followed by writing a small number of words in the afternoon (this way I don’t forget where my novel is going and waste precious time groping around, trying to get back on track). However, I am definitely going to focus my attention more fully on one thing at once and see if doing so improves my productivity.

Updates when I’ve come to some conclusions about whether this new schedule works – or whether it makes no difference at all.