This Writing Life: Novels vs. Short Stories

[Note: I suspect I may have covered this in a blog post some time ago, but as I’m writing both at the moment, it seemed like a good time to look at the issue again.]

There seems to be a piece of writing advice that, as a new writer, you find cropping up every now and again: that the best way to break into the fiction market is to publish a few short stories first, then move on to novels once you’ve built up your name. Now, regardless of how true that is any more – and regardless of the state of the short fiction market, which is a whole other blog post – there’s something about this piece of advice that has never rung true for me. The simple problem is that novels and short stories feel, to me, to be entirely different beasts and just because you can write one, there’s no guarantee you can write the other.

Certainly, there is crossover. Any ability to string a sentence together, hone a plot or create a character is going to have some bearing on both. The problem I’ve found, though, is that you really have to learn the two art forms separately and that learning to write decent short stories is every bit as difficult as writing novels. I’ve spent close to eight years writing novels now, and I think I’m finally approaching one or two that are of publishable quality. Short stories though? I’ve only taken those up seriously in the last year and, although I think I’m learning fast, most of what I’m producing is still pretty dire.

Some of this comes down to reading. I’ve been an avid reader of novels all my life, but short stories are something I’ve barely scratched the surface of. As I read more short fiction and study in more depth the way good stories are put together, I have no doubt that my own will improve immeasurably.

I really do think some study will be involved. It just seems  that short stories are harder to write, or at least to write well. Writing a novel is an act of perseverance above all else, but short stories seem to require so much more skill – to fit a whole plot, with fully developed characters and world (or a least a sense that all these things are fully developed in the background) into a few thousand words seems beyond me – and then there’s the skill of coming up with ideas that will fit comfortably in that few thousand words in the first place, which is one I’m struggling with too.

So, if some improvement in my short stories will come from reading more of them, what about the rest? That looks like it’s going to have to come from sheer bloody-minded practice – simply writing as many short stories as I can. Eight years to get reasonable novels? I suspect it might take me twice that to manage a decent short story. Good thing I like a challenge!

This Writing Life: Binge-Writing vs. Binge-Reading

First up: I’ve subtly changed the name of these blog posts, from ‘The Writing Life’ to ‘This Writing Life’. The latter seems more appropriate, because I’m really concentrating on my own writing issues. I’ve always said that if these posts help other people, that’s fantastic, but I write them primarily to think through writing problems that are on my mind. Anyway, on to the post.

I’ve been thinking this week about my time use and habits in both reading and writing and how the two differ, sometimes quite drastically. There is a standard piece of writing advice that runs thus: ‘Write Every Day’ (the alternative to this is often called ‘binge-writing’, where you only write perhaps one day a week, but sit down for hours at a time and try to get thousands of words down in that one session). If you’ve frequented any writing blogs or advice pages, there’s a pretty good chance you’ll have come across this before. It’s advice that I do tend to stick to, as I find that not keeping to a schedule means that I forget what I wanted to write next, lose the tone/voice of what I was writing or start to lose enthusiasm for it. (The exception here is the writing break I mentioned in an earlier post, but that was a break between projects, rather than taking a few days off when I had something to work on.)

So, I usually write every day, but my reading habits have become very different. When I pick up a new book, I tend to start reading it quite slowly, only a handful of pages a day. I may also have days where I don’t touch whatever I’m reading at all. Then, somewhere past the halfway point of the book, I suddenly decide that I want to finish it and have huge reading binges, sometimes spending a whole afternoon with a book in my hand. My writing-reading habits have become the ultimate expression of steady hard work vs. creative bingeing.

Some of this, I realise, is down to time constraints. I generally make time every morning for writing, but reading doesn’t always enjoy the same privilege and has to be crammed into small slots of time, until I have an afternoon free to indulge. I think there’s something more at work than just time though. I think, perhaps, there are parts of me that enjoy both steady work and bingeing, but because trying to accomplish both with writing would probably just hurt my head, I’ve managed to split them up between two different activities.

Finally, a question for any writers or readers out there: how do you find your time use in writing and reading compares? If you’re a reader but not a writer, how do your reading patterns fit in with the rest of your life – with any creative endeavours, with work, with other entertainment?

10/05/10 Word Metrics and Reading

It’s been a busy week for me, after spending the weekend before last away from home. I’ve been pressing ahead with a new novel and editing a second, whilst trying to keep up with my reading, so I thought I’d make a quick mention of my progress in both areas.

Words-wise, the new novel stands at 9638 words, and I’ll perhaps hit 10k by the end of the afternoon. It feels like a lot of words when I think about what’s happened so far, but I’m trying to go for a slightly slower, more thoughtful pace this time. Well, that’s my plan. Thinking about it, I’ve actually managed to fit two chases and three fights into those first nine thousand words, so maybe events are moving quicker than I imagine.

Anyway, that brings my yearly total up to a respectable 46579, not bad at all considering I took a month off writing altogether, as I talked about in my last post.

As for the reading, I’m currently about halfway through ‘The Crystal Cave’ by Mary Stewart, which follows the life of Merlin in 5th century Britain. I’ve read it before and am enjoying it as much as always, having decided to reread it because the time period and setting overlaps neatly with what I’m working on at the moment.

I’m also – very slowly – reading ‘2666’ by Robert Bolano. I’ve decided to read each of the five parts with a brief pause between them (I’ll probably go back to it after finishing ‘The Crystal Cave’) and have just finished the first part. So far, I’m not really sure what to think. I don’t particularly like the characters and I’m not even sure I can tell them apart, either in dialogue or in personalities. I’m not sure I can tell what the overall plot arc is about either – is this a book about a German scholar or about murders in a Mexican town? I’m assuming what seem like two unrelated plots at the moment will come together later on, but I suspect I might have to read quite a lot more to find out how.

The Writing Life: Taking Time Off

I’ve mentioned here before that this year I decided to keep a running total of my entire word count for the year (which comes to around 40k at this point, in case anyone’s interested). Looking at this running total today though, I noticed something interesting: I’ve just taken almost exactly a month off writing new words, be they part of a novel or short story. I’ve done a lot of planning and editing, but until the start of this week, it had been a month since I’d written anything new.

There are, quite clearly, dangers to doing this. The only way to improve your writing is to write and sometimes it’s the very act of writing that actually brings inspiration. Stop writing for too long and it can be incredibly difficult to get back into the habit of it – there’s a very good reason that many authors suggest writing every day.

Despite all this though, taking a break has been exactly what I needed. Writing too much without any clear goal in mind is, for me, exhausting, effectively sucking all the joy out of writing and turning it into a chore. Taking a month off allowed me to decide what I want to work on next and to build up, from a combination for research and planning, the enthusiasm to dive into it. It’s not just this one project though: with a month off writing, I quickly began to miss the whole process and was reminded that I do this because I’m passionate about it, not because I’m being forced to.

Taking time off writing may not work for everyone, particularly if you feel you’re in danger of giving up entirely, but it can equally help give you a fresh perspective on your work, reminding you how much you love it and helping you decide which direction to head in next. Perhaps, in future, I’ll set a definite date for starting writing again after any breaks I take, but I certainly won’t rule out taking them in the first place.

28/04/10: General Updatery

My life seems to be composed of too many things to do and not enough time to do them at the moment, so I thought I’d do a quick update on what I’ve been up to.

Writing: I’m working on two entirely different projects at the moment, one in the very earliest of starting stages (a fair bit of planning and about 1500 words written), the other getting closer and closer to completion as I press on with editing. Whether working on two things at once is wise remains to be seen, but I’m managing to focus on both, so there doesn’t seem to be any point putting one aside.

Reading: I’ve just finished C.E. Murphy’s ‘Heart of Stone’, as my previous review shows. I’ve also been rereading ‘Emma’, by Jane Austen, for at least the second and I think probably the third time. After that, I’ll probably pick up something a bit different – ‘2666’ and ‘Cloud Atlas’ are both on my bookshelf and both are starting to intrigue me. But then there’s my craving for some good, old-fashioned epic/heroic fantasy, for which I have a copy of James Barclay’s ‘Dawnthief’. I’ll probably end up reading two or three of these at once, just be to awkward.

Playing: Actually not a great deal this week, due to the larger than usual amount of work I’ve got done. Some World of Warcraft, some Mass Effect, some Final Fantasy XIII. Yup, pretty much evidence that I’ll play almost anything with the ‘RPG’ label attached.

And that’s it for this update. Hopefully I’ll get another Writing Life post out this week, before I disappear from the internet for a few days over the bank holiday weekend.

The Writing Life: Fear of Failure and Which Way Now?

I have something of a confession to make. For all my numerous projects and the hundreds of thousands of words that I’ve written in the last six months to a year, I’ve finished very little. There have been a few first drafts never revised, a couple of halfway finished then aborted novels or short stories, and plenty more false starts. Dozens of false starts, in fact.

In fact, it’s got to the point where I’ve backed myself into a bit of a corner. I’m so desperate to finish something – anything – that I’m convinced that I need to pick the exact right project to work on. If I make the wrong choice, I’ll never finish it, I reason, which will lead me to yet another abandoned novel. And that’s not somewhere I want to end up again. The problem is, I’m now simply too nervous to start anything new for fear of failing all over again.

It’s a vicious circle, I know. I make a half-hearted start on a hastily conceived idea, it all goes pear-shaped, I abandon it, I become too scared to start anything that I’ve put too much thought into, so I start something not properly thought out and it fails again…

So, I’m effectively stuck. I don’t know what to work on but I don’t want to fail again either. This is one of those writing problems that I don’t really know how to solve – I’m working from trial and error here – but I have decided that I need to work out a plan of action and stick to it. Here are my thoughts so far:

  1. Forget about the failures. So a few projects didn’t work out. So what? I need to put them aside if they’re really not working. I can come back to them later or I can move on to something new. The point is, I need to stop getting hung up on the number of unfinished works I have. There’s too much stress involved in worrying about them. They didn’t work out. End of.
  2. Research. To stop new projects failing, I need to put a lot more research and time into developing new ideas. I’m working on this one already, with a handful of books from the library and a list of similarly-themed fiction that I want to get my hands on. I’m also not going to start anything too quickly – I need time for these new ideas to sink in.
  3. Forget the schedule. I am not a published writer. I do not need to produce a book a year, or every six months. I can write entirely at my own pace, with no pressure whatsoever. This also links into giving new ideas and research time to sink in.
  4. Relax! This is is self-explanatory, really. The pressure I’m under is all coming from myself. I need to leave it behind.

Overall, I’m hoping that these simple points will help me discover which one of my many ideas I want to work on – and eventually help me finish whichever one I choose.

The Writing Life: It’s Editing Time

If there’s one writing related word which strikes fear into my heart every time I hear it, it’s ‘revision’. And yet, it’s an inescapable part of writing, be it a novel or a short story, so it’s something that I’ve realised I’m going to have to come to terms with. So much so, that I’ve decided to actually pay for the privilege.

Let me tell you something about my writing style: first drafts are easy. In most cases, I can whip out a first draft of 70-90,ooo words in a couple of months. No problem. But then it’s editing time and that’s where I fall down. I have at least half a dozen first drafts of novels, languishing on my computer hard drive because I can’t summon the will to edit them.

This is where the money comes in. I came to the decision that having so many finished first drafts but ultimately unfinished novels really should tell me something about where my writing career is headed if things don’t change – nowhere. I started thinking about what I could do to change things and remembered Holly Lisle’s How To Revise Your Novel course. I thought about it. I checked my bank balance. I thought about it some more, remembering how helpful Lisle’s numerous articles have been for me in the past. Then I took the plunge.

I had, in all honesty, more-or-less done a full edit of the novel I’m working on but I still felt there were problems with the world-building and character motivations. Not only that, but I wasn’t sure how I’d edited it. I need desperately to learn a revision method which I can use on all my novels, not just this one. A method which I can complete quickly and efficiently, without agonising over it for five times longer than it took me to complete the first draft. A method, in short, that a successfully – and repeatedly – published writer might use.

I’ve never made it a secret that I want to be a published novelist one day. I want my stories to be out there in the world, reaching as many readers as possible. So, signing up to this course has been my way of putting my money where my mouth is.

Will the course be beneficial to me in the end? I don’t know and I won’t know for several months yet. Still, even with the huge workload I’ve just dumped on myself, it feels a lot better to know that I’m doing something, anything, to improve my chances of doing this for the rest of my life without driving myself insane in the process.

The Writing Life: Creativity and Passion

(The usual caveat: I’m not a published writer and these writing posts are as much to help myself as others. Gain from them what you can, but please don’t take them as definitive advice.)

Over the weekend, I’ve found myself thinking a lot about passion when it comes to creativity and whether it’s as necessary as simple enjoyment. It occurred to me that there was a time when I first started writing – back when I was around 15 – when writing was very simply a passion. I spent a great deal of free time thinking about it and I couldn’t wait to get back to the keyboard.

Now though, I feel differently. I still enjoy writing very much and I really can’t imagine doing anything else with my life, but writing has become less an all-consuming passion and more a job that I really enjoy.

There are all sorts of problems with that statement, I realise. For one, it’s almost impossible to define ‘passion’. Secondly, my life has changed a lot since I was 15, so it’s difficult to compare now and then. There are still differences though and sometimes I find myself dwelling on them – I don’t tend to get caught up in daydreams about writing any more because I’m thinking about chores or work. I don’t rush to the keyboard to write either, although I do write every day.

I think that’s really the crux of the matter. Whilst I’m still an amateur, I’ve gone from writing only when I felt like it to the discipline of writing every day. I’m hoping to improve my chances of making a career of this by doing so, but whilst I don’t think discipline has stripped all the fun out of writing, it has sobered my view of it. Perhaps writing seems less of a romantic past-time than it once did.

Of course, the worry that lies behind all this runs thus: if I’m not passionate about what I’m writing, am I writing the wrong things? That’s the question I still can’t answer and which prompted this blog post. I really have no way of knowing. Maybe I’m just in a brief slump and the passion will have returned in a few weeks or months. Or perhaps I’ll realise that I have been writing the wrong things and I need to re-evaluate. For now though, all I can do is keep writing and keep enjoying what I can write.

The Writing Life: The Power of a Whiteboard

(The usual caveat: I’m not a published writer and these writing posts are as much to help myself as others. Gain from them what you can, but please don’t take them as definitive advice.)

A couple of weeks ago, I bought a very simple piece of office equipment: a whiteboard. I dutifully hung it above my desk and began using it every day to make a list of the writing tasks I wanted to accomplish. When each one was done, I would tick it off and, at the end of the day, I would wipe the whole list off, ready for the following writing day.

That all sounds incredibly simple, right? And it is simple, but I’ve also discovered that it’s having a powerful effect on the way I write.

To begin with, making a list of my goals requires me to come up with them before I even turn on my computer every morning. I have to actively think about where I am with each project and where I want them to go next. The act of doing this has revealed to me that I’m moving very, very slowly on some things but much quicker on others. For example, I write new words a lot quicker than I edit, which may mean I need to set aside more time for editing than writing. In terms of this list of goals, I might need to reduce the number of new words I want to write, to ensure that I have time to edit another chapter or short story.

Having a list of visible goals is also having a big impact. In the past, I’ve kept my to-do lists in my head, as I’m fairly good at organising without writing anything down. Now though, whenever I look up, I have to look at my progress throughout the day. Doing so lets me know whether I can relax and take a break, or whether I need to stop procrastinating and get back to work.

Having these goals visible also lets other people see them. Now, whenever my partner comes into my office, he can also see where I’ve got up to. Whilst I know that he’s not going to chastise me for not writing, knowing that my lazy days are no longer private often spurs me to work harder.

Despite all this though, I’ve quickly learnt that being flexible with my goals is very important. I’ll set smaller wordcount targets on days when I know I have to go out in the afternoon, for example. I also try not to be too hard on myself when I don’t accomplish everything I wanted, especially if something unexpected ate up my time. That’s why I clear the whiteboard every evening – there’s nothing more depressing than spending all morning staring at yesterday’s goals, bemoaning how behind you are. Better to set a fresh set of goals every day and not let the successes or failures of previous days get in the way.

Word Metrics 11/02/10

No new words today as I had a work meeting this morning and decided to spend the afternoon editing. This post is going to be incredibly quick too. Just long enough, in fact, for this:

I’m really, really close to being a third of the way through the book now, which pleases me immensely. Things have been moving slowly over the last few days, so I’ve decided the characters need to stop talking and start doing things. The last three chapters or so have been interesting to write, but the pace has definitely slowed so it’s time to pick it back up again.

My yearly total, then, stands at 20032. Can you tell I kept writing yesterday until I passed 20k?

Overall, my new writing schedule is really starting to show results. I’ve been setting myself goals every day too, which has really helped – and that’s what I’m going to talk about in my next Writing Life post. Which will be up tomorrow. See you then!