‘Silk Road Fantasy’, or Fantasy Set in Non-European Worlds

Earlier today, I saw a Twitter discussion of the recent increase in ‘Silk Road fantasy’ novels, or fantasy that is set outside the Western Europe-influenced settings that so dominate the genre. This is a topic I find dear to my heart – it’s a section of the genre that I’ve been continually searching out for a number of years, and which I find tends to draw together better-developed fantastic worlds, poetic writing, and – surprisingly frequently – more compelling female characters than is unusual in fantasy.

I can’t exactly put my finger on what drew me to non-European fantasy, particularly as it was authors like Tolkien and Terry Brooks who inspired me to write fantasy at all. The third novel I wrote, aged 18, was set in a decidedly non-European desert city, but I don’t remember anything specific at the time spurring me to choose that setting. I’ve moved onto a range of non-European worlds in my writing over the years, both because I was reading so many excellent similar books, and because fantasy set in yet another version of Western Europe was ceasing to feel ‘fantastic’ at all.

This isn’t a post about me, though, but rather a celebration of a whole host of writers and novels I adore. I want to share a couple of links to sites mentioned in that Twitter discussion. In the first, Saladin Ahmed has compiled a list of his ‘Top Ten Epic Fantasy/Sword & Sorcery Novels set in ‘Nonwestern’ Worlds’, and there are some excellent choices. ‘A Shadow in Summer’ and ‘Range of Ghosts’ both featured in my last reading update, whilst I read ‘Acacia’ when it first came out; N.K. Jemisin and Amanda Downum, meanwhile, are two of my favourite authors in any genre. Ahmed’s own novel, alongside ‘The Desert of Souls’ are both on my ‘to be read’ list, whilst ‘The Scrolls of Years’ is new to me, but looks to be exactly the sort of novel I’d love.

The second link is to this post by Paul Weimer over on SF Signal, and is where I first saw the term ‘Silk Road fantasy’. He mentions an excellent selection of authors, with a fair bit of overlap with Ahmed’s post – the comments are also a goldmine. Chris Wooding! Mazarkis Williams! Aliette de Bodard! These are all authors I’ve read and enjoyed, and there are many more to discover in those comments. I am heartened both by how many of these excellent books I’ve already read (or at least have waiting to be read), and by how many more there are out there waiting for me.

Do I wish there were more? Of course. Could I happily read two or three non-European fantasies for every European fantasy? Absolutely, if not more! Still, if you’re a fantasy reader who’s been looking for a way to expand their reading horizons, I can highly recommend every single author I’ve mentioned in this post – and now I hope your ‘to be read’ list is starting to look as monumental as mine!

On SFF, Community and Blogging

It’s not often I spend a great deal of time on Twitter (I simply don’t have time, and my life doesn’t revolve around my PC or phone), but every time I’ve dropped in on it lately, I seem to find a similar situation developing. I follow, not surprisingly, a large number of writers and people in the SFF (science-fiction and fantasy) community, and in doing so I’ve noticed something of a pattern. Every week or two, a new controversy seems to rise up, get everyone in a fluster for a few days, and then gradually die down. I’m not going to detail these controversies – they’re out there if you really care to look for them, spread across Twitter and Facebook and multiple blogs/forums.

In the past, I’ve taken the same approach to just about every hoo-haa: namely, trying to ignore them. Well, perhaps ‘ignore’ is the wrong word. Many of these controversies arise out of genuinely important issues, such as race and gender in the genre community, or harassment, or discrimination – these are topics I do care about, and I want to know what’s going on. However, I’ve purposefully tried not to get involved in these internet skirmishes; I simply don’t have an argumentative side, and confrontation of any kind tends to make me feel physically sick. For the sake of my own sanity, I choose to stay out of it.

However, in recent weeks, that’s been hard. Short of leaving Twitter altogether (which seems a shame, as it’s so frequently a repository of excellent genre news and discussion), it’s impossible to ignore these blow-ups. One of the latest revolved around women in SFF, and how little some people want us there – reading their arguments, some of them genuinely nasty, was enough to leave me feeling exhausted and upset. If so many people don’t want me here, I found myself thinking, why am I even bothering? Why don’t I abandon all genre sites and blogs, never attend another convention, stay off Twitter, even stop buying books?

It’s easy, and tempting, to retreat in the face of such negativity. There are days when I can’t face doing anything else. However, whilst I’m not the arguing type, I am bloody stubborn. It takes an awful lot to put me off for long, and being part of the SFF community is no exception.

This, then, is a mini manifesto, of sorts. As I said before, for the sake of my own sanity, I don’t intend to embroil myself in too many internet scuffles. However, that doesn’t mean I’ll ignore them entirely. I choose to counter all the nastiness floating around the internet with my own small piece of positivity: by blogging and tweeting about those books and authors I love, by promoting them to anyone who’ll listen, and by continuing to both read and write the sort of fiction I want to see more of in SFF.

Like the majority of people in this genre community, I am just one small fish in a very large pond, but it’s an ecosystem we all have to work hard to maintain if we want it to be a place everyone can live.

Spring 2012 Reading

As usual when I do these occasional book posts, I’m not going to go through every single thing I’ve read over the last six months. Instead, I just want to focus on the books and authors I’ve loved, in the hopes that others will discover their work for the first time and love them as much as I have. So, what’s on the list this time?

‘Tigana’ – Guy Gavriel Kay.     I’m going to start with my absolute favourite. It’s fair to say that I’ve read a good number of fantasy books, and that Tigana has got to be one of the most accomplished I’ve ever come across. It’s long, and complex, and beautifully written, and more subtle than the majority of books I’ve read in any genre. Kay’s characters are remarkably well-drawn, and the novel as a whole is heart-breaking half a dozen times over. If you can read Tigana and not cry at Dianora’s story at least once, then I’m fairly certain you’ve misplaced your heart.

‘The Kingdom of Gods’ and ‘The Killing Moon’ – N.K. Jemisin.     With these two books, Jemisin has ended one trilogy and started a duology (of which the second book is already available). I’d be lying if I said I loved the two equally – The Kingdom of Gods just edged ahead for me, due to already knowing the characters and having loved them through the two previous books. The Killing Moon is an excellent fantasy too, though, with an Egyptian-inspired setting, a brilliant magic system and Jemisin’s strong characterisation. I think I’ve said before that Jemisin is on my (very short) list of authors whose books I’ll buy no matter what they write – these two latest books have only confirmed that.

‘The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle’ – Haruki Murukami.     This is the first Murukami novel I read and so far my favourite (I also read Kafka on the Shore recently, but it didn’t really click with me). It’s a strange, meandering, surreal book, and no matter where it might get shelved in bookshops, it seems to me a sort of modern fantasy of the urban-but-having-nothing-to-do-with-vampires variety. Instead you get war stories and wig factories, a missing wife and, er… a bloke who spends a lot of time sitting in a well. It sounds incredibly dull, but there’s something about Murukami’s writing (in translation, of course) and the way he builds his plots that’s weirdly compelling.

‘Wither’ – Lauren DeStefano.     I don’t read a lot of YA fiction but Wither is an impressive debut from DeStefano and well worth a look. There’s more than a touch of The Handmaid’s Tale about it, with a cloistered world of husbands and multiple wives who don’t survive past their 20s. Some of the science might be a bit suspect, but this is a story about the characters most of all, with plenty of shades of grey in every personality, be they ostensibly hero or villain. I also thought it was wonderfully written, and I suspect DeStefano could be one to watch in coming years.

So, that’s what’s been taking up room on my bookshelves recently (and, ahem, being read when I should have been working). What about yours?

This Writing Life: Drawn to the Fantastic

A few weeks ago I looked back over the list of books I’ve read recently and confirmed something I’d already suspected: nearly everything I’d read over as much as the past eighteen months has been fantasy, and particularly epic fantasy. I decided, as I do from time to time, that I was going to make an effort to read a bit more widely. With this resolution, I went to the library and took out a couple of books from the ‘general fiction’ section. It wasn’t until I got home that I realised I’d, inadvertantly, picked up books with a strong fantastical element: one is sort of magical realism, but definitely contains some weirdness. The other is about demons.

The same thing happens every time I make that same resolution. No matter whether I intend it or not, everything I read (or at least all the fiction) contains something a little bit out of the ordinary, be it a talking cat in an otherwise ‘literary’ novel, or a grand, sweeping epic fantasy set in a secondary world. Now, you could argue that most fiction contains at least a little bit of the strange and unusual, but my reading habits go beyond that. Either consciously or unconsciously, I am always drawn to the fantastic, to something beyond the everyday world, to magic and weirdness and speculation.

The same goes for my writing: everything I write has at least some tinge of the fantastic to it, no matter the setting. And that’t not because I want to be known as a ‘fantasy author’. It’s simply what I enjoy, what my mind turns to every time I come up with a story. Without that weird streak, fiction always seems to be a little bit… well, boring.

I think all writers are the same. No matter their genre, there are certain subjects, certain conceits or situations or characters, that they keep coming back to, again and again (and, in terms of style, certain ‘crutch’ words or phrases too, but that’s another post). For me it’s an element of the fantastic, but it’s also super-competent female characters, and vast landscapes, and bittersweet endings. And that’s only at the moment. Whilst some aspects (those competent female characters) have been common in my writing ever since I started, others come and go – I seem to alternate between setting novels in vast forests and vast cities, for example.

So, as a writer or an artist, what do you keep coming back to – what genres, settings, character-types or situations? Do you do it consciously, or not? And do you think there’s a value in identifying these recurring tropes – and in trying to do something different?

A Bit of Fantasy Nostalgia

For some reason, my partner and I have talked about Choose Your Own Adventure books (and their equivalents from other publishers) several times recently. We both seem to have had just one of these books each, which we remember fondly: his was from the Fighting Fantasy line, and mine… Well, until yesterday I couldn’t quite remember what it was called. I knew it was about a circus, with characters called Petra and something like Lila. It also had a pegasus in it, and owl bears. In a fit of nostalgia, I decided to try to find it online. The result? THIS:

Now, isn’t that an amazing piece of sheer 80s-ness, if ever there was one. Props to this site for full details of the book, which turns out to have been called ‘Circus of Fear’. It was actually part of the Dungeons & Dragons world, although I’d never heard of D&D at the time, and I don’t think I ever noticed their name on the book.

Now, I’m not recommending anyone go out and find a copy of this book – it was probably pretty cheesy even by 80s fantasy standards. Still, I’m struck by just how much I remember about it. The pegasus, the character names (the girl was actually ‘Laela’, but I was close), the owl bears, the circus, and that teardrop on the front cover, which I believe was a crystallised pegasus tear owned by the main character. I’m not going to claim that this book gave me my love of fantasy, either (that was Tolkien), but it must have been somewhere in the mix. I certainly loved it when I was little.

Really, this is nothing but a bit of nostalgia, so if anyone would like to add their childhood favourites in the comments (bonus points for 80s fantasy!), please do. On another note, I managed to dredge up the full listings of this book, the name of which I couldn’t previously remember, in about ten minutes flat. Isn’t it amazing what you can find on the internet?