‘Shadowland’ – Rhiannon Lassiter

I was lucky enough to get hold of a review copy of ‘Shadowland’ by Rhiannon Lassiter in last month’s LibraryThing Early Review books. As I’ve posted my review over on the LibraryThing site, I thought I’d post it here too. As I point out at the end, it’s well worth reading, but probably best to read the series in the correct order – which I didn’t!




Beginning in the Great Library, something of a hub between worlds, SHADOWLAND follows the continuing adventures of four teenagers from Earth and their various non-Earth allies. Most of the action takes place on two very different worlds, Chalice and Fenrisnacht, splitting the main characters into two groups with plots which don’t interconnect, but which advance what characters and readers alike know of a group called the Wheel and the threat it poses.

As an author’s note at the back of the book warns, SHADOWLAND is not a book with a clear-cut beginning or end. It’s abundantly obvious that a great deal has happened to the main characters prior to this book, and that there’s a lot more to come. Still, even without having read the previous two books in the series, there are enough hints about backstory for SHADOWLAND to be both enjoyable and understandable.

There’s certainly a lot to enjoy here, too. The two very different worlds, as well as the Library, are described sparingly but are easy to visual. There’s plenty of in the way of action and plot revelations too, with very little unnecessary exposition to slow down the rapid pace. However, it’s the characters and their interactions that are at the heart of the book, with Laura’s deviousness and Morgan breaking out of her fugue providing the two most fascinating viewpoints.

There are some frustrations, though. Alex’s story, in particular, feels like a bit of a placeholder, giving him something to do while he waits for a chance to meet up with the other main characters again. A convincing antagonist is also lacking, as the Wheel are a fairly vague threat and their leader proves too easy to escape from.

Still, there’s a lot to recommend SHADOWLAND, particularly for readers who want a believable YA fantasy that doesn’t revolve around an unconvincing romance or indeed any fantasy that doesn’t take place in a pseudo-Medieval world. I would take the advice of the author’s note though and start with the first two books in the series, as I feel SHADOWLAND would be even more satisfying after reading those.

Fantasy, Lit. Fic. and the Human Condition

[Note: this post was originally written at about midnight after getting home from work, so if it’s a bit confused, I’ll apologise in advance. Still, I think it more-or-less captures what I wanted to say, so I’m going to leave it mostly unedited.]

Every time I think about the genre of literary fiction (if it can be said to be a genre of its own – for the purposes of this post, I’m assuming just that), I struggle to put into words why I read so little of it. Finally however, something has crystallised in my head and suddenly it makes a lot more sense.

It boils down to one simple thing: literary fiction, we are told, exists to elucidate the human condition. Admirable, certainly, but that’s also where my problem lies. For me, it’s not enough. (I have other problems with much of lit. fic, but I’m not going to go into those right now.)

Now, it would be easy enough to argue that shedding light on the human condition is the greatest feat literature can accomplish and I don’t think I’d argue with that. However, if I really want to understand what it means to be human, I need to go out and fall in love, lose someone, feel angry and joyful and scared; in short, to live a full life, no matter how happy or sad. I need to experience what it is to be human to really learn anything about myself. Then, when I read a book, it might help me to understand what it is I’ve learnt from experience, but it’s less likely to teach me anything new.

This is where fantasy, my genre of choice, comes in. The very best fantasy, just like the best lit. fic., will also help me to understand the human condition, but it will do so accompanied by battles and airships and monsters. It will let me experience again those aspects of humanity that I’ve felt before, alongside the aspects I will never get to feel (because, let’s face it, I’m never going to get to pilot a steam-powered airship). It will entertain as well as enlighten – and I’ve got to say, it’s been a long time since I’ve been entertained by a prize-winning literary novel, no matter how enlightening it is.

So, the next time someone tells me about this really great lit. fic. book, one that will help me understand the human condition, I might just find myself replying, “Is that all?”

The Reading Meme

I realise I’ve fallen behind with my blogging lately. I’m not going to make excuses, as all the work I’ve taken on recently has been of my own making. No-one’s tell me I need to work on a novel, edits for another and a short story at the same time, let alone the second novel idea that I’ve been fiddling around with this morning. Anyway, as my last post talked a bit about my reading habits, I thought I’d elaborate by filling in the reading meme I came across on Speculative Horizons a few weeks ago.

.

Do you snack while you read? If so, favourite reading snack:

I don’t tend to eat much while reading, though I will usually have a cup of tea or coffee at my elbow.

What is your favourite drink while reading?

Oops, already answered that one. I suppose I could elaborate that I tend towards Earl Grey or Ceylon tea. As for coffee, I’m the coffee-fan’s worst nightmare: cheap instant decaf, with loads of milk. Luvverly.

Do you tend to mark your books as you read, or does the idea of writing in books horrify you?

I’m not entirely against writing in books, because some of the second-hand textbooks I’ve bought have had really useful or hilarious comments scribbled in the margins. (As an aside, I once had a book from my uni library in which someone had written ‘This is the most pretentious, useless, waste of time article I’ve ever read’, before going on to describe in some detail why that was the case.) I don’t really have any need to write in books any more though.

How do you keep your place while reading a book? Bookmark? Dog-ears? Laying the book flat open?

Dog-earing and laying books flat does horrify me because it damages the book without adding anything worthwhile. I have a selection of bookmarks, including a magnetic rabbit, a playing card advertising a poker website (gained from another library book), old till receipts and a ‘safety card’, with phone numbers for various security services and advice lines around the uni on it. Pretty much anything I pick up at the time, basically.

Fiction, non-fiction, or both?

Most fiction, although I’m trying to get back into more non-fiction. The amount of reading I had to do for my degree spoiled non-fiction for me somewhat, but I picked up a book on Isabella de Medici recently so hopefully I’ll get round to that one soon.

Are you a person who tends to read to the end of a chapter, or can you stop anywhere?

I used to always read to the end of a chapter, but these days I have to fit my reading around all my other commitments, so I tend to just stop wherever necessary. This is most relevant when I get chance to read at work – I can’t just say “I’ll be with you when I’ve found out how this chapter ends” when a student has lost their library card or one of the printers has exploded (ok, maybe not exploded, but fixer-of-printers really should be part of my job description).

Are you the type of person to throw a book across the room or on the floor if the author irritates you?

I don’t think I’ve ever thrown a book because they don’t tend to irritate me enough to make me angry. The biggest insult I can give a book is to put it down and never pick it up again. If I don’t finish something, it must have been pretty dire.

If you come across an unfamiliar word, do you stop and look it up right away?

Sometimes, but only if I’m near a dictionary or computer. Usually I just keep reading, because I can usually get the gist of a sentence even if I don’t understand a word. Incidentally, this is a habit gained from reading adult books when I was a kid, and frequently coming across words I didn’t understand.

What are you currently reading?

2666 and the first of Christopher Tolkien’s Histories of Middle-Earth. I’m picking my way slowly through both of these though and have been for weeks. I’ve just gone back to them because I’m waiting for a whole load of Alt.Fiction related books to turn up in the post.

What is the last book you bought?

The four books I’m waiting for, actually. One each by Kim Lakin-Smith, Mark Chadbourn, Mark Charan Newton and Juliet McKenna. Before that, a handful of second-hand books from my local Oxfam Books and Music.

Are you the type of person that reads one book at a time, or can you read more than one?

Ever since I was little, I’ve tended to read two or three books at once (and frequently got comments from my parents along the lines of ‘how can you remember what’s happening in them all?’ I always could, even if I hadn’t looked at a book for months). I dropped this habit for a few years at uni, but I’ve gone back to it now. Not for any particular reason – it just seems practical and I think it makes me read more.

Do you have a favorite time/place to read?

Quiet evenings at work. The Poang chair in my office. Sitting on the bed. I prefer to read where it’s quiet – the TV is a big distraction, for example – but I can read just about anywhere.

Do you prefer series books or standalones?

I don’t really have a preference either way, although I will note that I rarely read past the first book in a series. The lack of resolution doesn’t bother me and I prefer to read the widest variety of authors possible, rather than plough through a whole twelve book series by one author, or whatever it may be.

Is there a specific book or author you find yourself recommending over and over?

K.J. Bishop’s The Etched City, which I’ve talked about on this blog before. As for authors in general, probably Alastair Reynolds and Steph Swainston.

How do you organize your books? (by genre, title, author’s last name, etc.)

Alphabetically, by author’s last name. Within author, by series order or by publication date for standalones. (I have a similar system for my hundreds of CDs too.) Then there’s the shelf for books waiting to be read, the manga shelf and the non-fiction shelves. I have a lot of bookcases and yeah, I know all this sounds quite obsessive – it is – but I like to be able to find things. Also can you tell my two jobs since uni have been in a bookshop and a library?



10/05/10 Word Metrics and Reading

It’s been a busy week for me, after spending the weekend before last away from home. I’ve been pressing ahead with a new novel and editing a second, whilst trying to keep up with my reading, so I thought I’d make a quick mention of my progress in both areas.

Words-wise, the new novel stands at 9638 words, and I’ll perhaps hit 10k by the end of the afternoon. It feels like a lot of words when I think about what’s happened so far, but I’m trying to go for a slightly slower, more thoughtful pace this time. Well, that’s my plan. Thinking about it, I’ve actually managed to fit two chases and three fights into those first nine thousand words, so maybe events are moving quicker than I imagine.

Anyway, that brings my yearly total up to a respectable 46579, not bad at all considering I took a month off writing altogether, as I talked about in my last post.

As for the reading, I’m currently about halfway through ‘The Crystal Cave’ by Mary Stewart, which follows the life of Merlin in 5th century Britain. I’ve read it before and am enjoying it as much as always, having decided to reread it because the time period and setting overlaps neatly with what I’m working on at the moment.

I’m also – very slowly – reading ‘2666’ by Robert Bolano. I’ve decided to read each of the five parts with a brief pause between them (I’ll probably go back to it after finishing ‘The Crystal Cave’) and have just finished the first part. So far, I’m not really sure what to think. I don’t particularly like the characters and I’m not even sure I can tell them apart, either in dialogue or in personalities. I’m not sure I can tell what the overall plot arc is about either – is this a book about a German scholar or about murders in a Mexican town? I’m assuming what seem like two unrelated plots at the moment will come together later on, but I suspect I might have to read quite a lot more to find out how.

28/04/10: General Updatery

My life seems to be composed of too many things to do and not enough time to do them at the moment, so I thought I’d do a quick update on what I’ve been up to.

Writing: I’m working on two entirely different projects at the moment, one in the very earliest of starting stages (a fair bit of planning and about 1500 words written), the other getting closer and closer to completion as I press on with editing. Whether working on two things at once is wise remains to be seen, but I’m managing to focus on both, so there doesn’t seem to be any point putting one aside.

Reading: I’ve just finished C.E. Murphy’s ‘Heart of Stone’, as my previous review shows. I’ve also been rereading ‘Emma’, by Jane Austen, for at least the second and I think probably the third time. After that, I’ll probably pick up something a bit different – ‘2666’ and ‘Cloud Atlas’ are both on my bookshelf and both are starting to intrigue me. But then there’s my craving for some good, old-fashioned epic/heroic fantasy, for which I have a copy of James Barclay’s ‘Dawnthief’. I’ll probably end up reading two or three of these at once, just be to awkward.

Playing: Actually not a great deal this week, due to the larger than usual amount of work I’ve got done. Some World of Warcraft, some Mass Effect, some Final Fantasy XIII. Yup, pretty much evidence that I’ll play almost anything with the ‘RPG’ label attached.

And that’s it for this update. Hopefully I’ll get another Writing Life post out this week, before I disappear from the internet for a few days over the bank holiday weekend.

‘Heart of Stone’ – C.E. Murphy

I feel like I’ve been going nowhere far too fast this week, so I don’t have a lot to blog about, but here’s another of my reviews for the LibraryThing Early Reviewers scheme. It’s another urban fantasy, as there seems to be a real lack of epic fantasy up for review. Anyway, here it is:

There seems to be an increasing trend in urban fantasy for writers to do something different. Supernatural beings who aren’t vampires or werewolves. Heroines who don’t literally kick ass. Enter Margrit Knight, a New York lawyer who’s about to be sucked into a world existing alongside our own. It’s a world which does, in fact, include vampires, but also gargoyles and a number of other ‘Old Races’ who aren’t quite the norm in urban fantasy. Margrit herself isn’t quite the norm either – aside from the occasional slap, she fights her enemies with words and intellect rather than violence.

As a consequence, Heart of Stone is somewhat slower paced than some urban fantasies I’ve read recently, though that doesn’t equate to boring. Murphy executes a sense of rising tension skilfully throughout the book, both in Margrit’s investigations and in her relationship with the gargoyle Alban Korund. It’s this relationship which forms the core emotional impact of the story and it’s a fascinating relationship, although it does mean that some of the other characters are lost by the wayside as the book progresses – Tony, for example, a key player in the first half of the book, is largely absent from the second half.

There are other problems too, although not huge ones. There are too many similar names, for one thing – Cam, Cole, Cara, Chelsea. I particularly struggled to tell Cam and Cole apart, as they’re introduced at about the same time and often appear in the same scenes. One is male and one female, but both the names sound male to my ears, hence my problem. Then there are all the loose ends. It’s clear that Heart of Stone is the beginning of a series, with many of the secondary characters feeling as if they’ll be more important in later books. Personally, I felt there were a few too many of these secondary characters, some of which didn’t really have enough to do.

Overall, Heart of Stone is probably best read by those who are already urban fantasy fans and those looking for a new series to become invested in. The characters here are strong enough and Murphy’s writing skillful enough to keep the interest of any fan, but it’s too clearly the start of series to work for a casual reader wanting only a single book.

‘Frost Moon’ – Anthony Francis

Not a lot to report here – I’ve been reading a lot, poking around with various writing projects and generally stuffing my brain full of inspiration. As part of all that reading though, I thought I’d put up another review. This one was originally written for the LibraryThing Early Reviewers programme (you can find my profile here if you’re interested).

***

Dakota Frost is a magical tattoo artist living in an alternate Atlanta, a city where vampires, werebeasts and witches live openly alongside the non-magical population. Not only that, but she’s a Skindancer, able to bring her own magical tattoos to life. Within the first handful of pages of the book, Dakota has been pulled into a police case involving the grisly find of a magical tattoo no longer attached to its owner, but, as the best magical tattooist in the southeast, it quickly becomes clear that the police aren’t the only ones with an interest in Dakota.

Frost Moon gets off to a swift start and the pace barely lets up throughout the entire book, as numerous plotlines and characters first appear and then begin to converge. The characters around Dakota are a fascinating bunch and all very much outsiders in ‘mainstream’ society – they all have their role to play in the story, without being there for the story’s sake, and are all interesting in their own right.

At the heart of the book though is Dakota herself, a strong, sometimes masculine, woman who still isn’t afraid to admit when she’s scared or in pain. It’s her unique and compelling voice that drives the story, injecting both moments of humour and of emotion into the narrative.

I only had two real niggles with Frost Moon, both of them minor. Firstly, the end of the book feels rushed and could have done with a few more pages to make the denouement more powerful for the reader. Secondly, the majority of the male characters Dakota meets are both strong and attractive – so attractive that Dakota never seems able to decide which one she likes most. By the end of the book, something of a romantic relationship has developed, but it doesn’t grow much within this book and feels like it’s being held back for a sequel.

That said though, Frost Moon is a book that I’m eagerly awaiting the sequel to. The tight writing style, swift pace and Dakota’s compelling narration make this one of the best debut urban fantasies I’ve read in a long time.

‘Above the Snowline’ – Steph Swainston

My brain is still stuck in ‘what the hell am I doing mode?’, so no writing news to report. I have been reading though, so I thought I’d post my thoughts on Steph Swainston’s newest book, Above the Snowline.

For anyone who’s familiar with the series, Above the Snowline takes place before the previous three books, relating the story of Jant coming to terms with his Rhydanne heritage as he tries to mediate between Awians and Rhydanne over the construction of a new manor in Darkling. Rather than simply tell the story from Jant’s perspective, we also get chapters from other participants in the book’s events, including Lightning and Raven, governor of Carniss. At first, I’ll admit I found this a bit off-putting – it takes a while to get to Jant’s chapters, when I’d wanted to hear from him straight away. However, splitting the POVs this way gives the book a number of different voices and tones, which made it more interesting without overly complicating the plot.

In terms of plot, I won’t attempt to summarise any more than I have above. Above the Snowline feels deceptively simple when you’re reading it, but there’s a lot going on: dealings with the Rhydanne, Awian politics, frontier living and Jant’s relationship with Dellin. No single plotline dominates the others and instead all entwine tightly together, moving the story along quickly to a satisfying end.

My one main concern with Above the Snowline was the description of setting which, whilst evocative, sometimes runs on longer than I would have liked. Still, Swainston’s writing is strong enough to make descriptions of forests and glaciers and mountains compelling, lending a real sense of place to the novel – and it’s refreshing to come across a setting in a fantasy that isn’t yet another faux-Medieval civilisation. In fact, from the Rhydanne I got more of a sense of an European prehistoric people. In the descriptions of their lifestyle, including things like meat butchery and flint knapping, I was immediately reminded of my archaeology degree. Swainston’s biography says she’s worked as an archaeologist and it shows in the Rhydanne. (Incidentally, the particular scene involving flint knapping vividly recalled archaeological evidence from a particular Neanderthal cave site, but I won’t say more than that or it’ll spoil the story!) However, don’t let me give you the impression that the Rhydanne’s lifestyle is described in a dry, scholarly manner, as it’s actually vivid and beautifully realised, with the archaeology visible only if you know what you’re looking for.

I’ll admit, finally, that Above the Snowline wasn’t my favourite of Swainston’s books, simply because I never really grew to like the Rhydanne – but I’m not sure the reader is supposed to. They remain fascinating but ultimately as bizarre to modern thinking as our ancient ancestors would likely seem, were we to meet them today. Still, Above the Snowline is beautifully written, tightly plotted and compelling, without a single extraneous scene. Like the rest of the novels in this loose series, it stands well above most current fantasy and has already got me impatient for the next installment.

What I’m Reading

My brain is firmly stuck in ‘what on earth is this damn novel about?’ mood this week. I’m both trying to decide whether the novel I’m currently working on is worth finishing (it’s become so complicated that I’ve lost track of what it’s about and whether any of it makes sense) and brainstorming ideas for a new novel. When you’re working on something difficult, that new shiny project always looks so much more fun and appealing, so what I’m now trying to work out is whether it really would be more fun or if my brain is just playing tricks on me out of laziness.

All of which was a long way of saying that I can’t muster the thought power to do a writing post today, so I’m going to just jot down a few notes about what I’m reading.

First up: Above the Snowline by Steph Swainston. I loved the rest of this (loose) series – of which Above the Snowline is the fourth – so much that I’ve actually bought this in hardback, less than a week after it came out. I virtually never buy hardbacks unless they’re second hand. I haven’t actually started reading yet – that’s what I plan to spend the rest of the afternoon doing.

Secondly: Pretty Monsters by Kelly Link. This is Link’s newest short story collection and actually another book that I bought in hardback, simply because the design of the book is so gorgeous. I’d heard good things about Kelly Link but never read any of her work beforehand. I’ve read the first three stories so far, of which two were very enjoyable and the third – ‘Magic for Beginners’ – I absolutely loved. It’s one of those stories that made me ache somewhere deep inside simply because I wish I’d come up with it. I’m looking forward to getting a chance to read the rest, but I did specifically start reading a short story collection so that I could easily put it aside when Above the Snowline turned up, so I’ll probably get back to Pretty Monsters next week.

Finally: The Fountainhead by Ayn Rand. I’m only forty pages into this, but I picked it up purely because I kept hearing Rand’s name mentioned (usually not in a very flattering manner) and didn’t know anything about her work. This is one of those books that I may not finish but which I had to take a look at out of sheer curiosity – if I ever get around to reading Twilight, it’ll be for the same reason. I don’t really have anything to say, good or bad, about The Fountainhead yet and I suspect it’s something I’m going to pick away at very slowly over several months.

And that’s it for now. I have an afternoon to spend in the Fourlands.

Initial Thoughts on my Sony Pocket E-reader

A couple of weeks ago, I decided to splash out with the last of my wages from my bookselling job and buy an e-reader. I’d wanted one for a while but had set myself a point I had to reach before I could get one: I had to have accumulated free e-books that would have cost more to buy in paperback than the cost of an e-reader.

I’m talking about completely legal free e-books here, for the record. It’s taken me between six months and a year to amass so many, from author websites, giveaways and particularly the Suvudu library. I also cheated a little bit – the price of all these books would probably come to about £100 and the e-reader was a little bit more than that.

Anyway, I want to talk a little bit about the device itself and what I’m making of it. It’s a Sony Pocket, one of the cheapest on the market from any manufacturer. Physically, I love the way it looks and feels – sleek and lightweight (a bit heavier than a small paperback, admittedly, but also lighter than a big hardback, so a very reasonable weight), with a slick metallic finish and a back that feels slightly velvety when you rest your fingers on it. There’s also the added advantage of being able to read and drink a cup of tea at the same time. You can hold the Pocket in one hand and still turn pages, something I could never manage with a paperback. (Okay, I know this sounds stupid, but I drink a lot of tea when I’m reading!)

Other advantages of the Pocket include its ability to read all the major e-formats (PDFs were a big concern for me and although changing the font size does alter their formatting sometimes, they are still easily readable on the device), its long battery life (I’m estimating about a month with my personal reading habits) and its ability to store multiple bookmarks on multiple books (mine’s keeping my place in four books at the moment!).

There are drawbacks, of course, so let’s get them out of the way. You don’t get to see the beautiful cover art or interior layouts of your books – pictures are all in black and white, whilst many free e-books don’t come with covers at all. An e-reader has to be recharged, although on current usage, I think the battery on the Pocket will last about a month for me, as I’ve said. Turning the pages isn’t instant: the screen flashes black before it clears, although this is something I’ve got used to. Most annoyingly, the device does occasionally freeze and have to be reset, which a physical book is clearly never going to do.

For me though, an e-reader has a very specific function, which outweighs all of these complaints. I use it to read free downloaded e-books and short stories, which I would never have read otherwise (I hate reading on a computer screen, which has meant that my consumption of short stories has been very low recently). I can try out authors I wouldn’t have tried any other way with only the cost of the initial outlay for the e-reader – a cost which has already been paid, no matter how many more e-books I acquire. When it comes to actually paying for books, I’ll still continue to buy physical copies, even if I read the first book in the series in electronic form.

Overall, the Sony Pocket is a nice little device, easy to use and much more practical than reading on a computer screen, if you’ve got a lot of electronic reading to do. E-readers obviously aren’t for everyone, but if you’ve got a use for one without having much money, the Pocket is a great low-price alternative that doesn’t limit you to reading one file format.