My Not-Quite Cultural Olympiad: South Africa

[Details of what my Not-Quite Cultural Olympiad is all about are here.]

So far in my Not-Quite Cultural Olympiad I’ve covered two continents and two forms of art, so it seems only appropriate to move on to a third of each, with the country of South Africa and a piece of literature. For those who’ve been reading this blog for a while, it’s probably not difficult to guess where I’m going with this: ‘Zoo City’, by Lauren Beukes.

I really can’t sum up Zoo City better than the official blurb, so here it is:

Zinzi has a Sloth on her back, a dirty 419 scam habit and a talent for finding lost things. But when a little old lady turns up dead and the cops confiscate her last paycheck, she’s forced to take on her least favourite kind of job – missing persons.

Being hired by reclusive music producer Odi Huron to find a teenybop pop star should be her ticket out of Zoo City, the festering slum where the criminal underclass and their animal companions live in the shadow of hell’s undertow.

Instead, it catapults Zinzi deeper into the maw of a city twisted by crime and magic, where she’ll be forced to confront the dark secrets of former lives – including her own.

That’s a pretty good description of a book that’s actually quite difficult to describe. It’s perhaps halfway between an urban fantasy and a crime novel with a bit of cyberpunk thrown in, but far different to what I’ve read in any of those genres. When I read it last year – and talked about it on the blog – I noted that, “Fantastical elements aside, Johannesburg comes across as both very familiar and very alien. More importantly, Zinzi is the most real character I’ve read in a long time. This is the sort of thing I want when I read urban fantasy, with its darkness, modernity, edginess and humour. I loved it.”

Maybe this is a bit of a cheat: I’m using the official blurb to tell you about the book and my own review from last year to detail how much I like it. What more can I honestly say though, to persuade you just how good this book is? That it won the Arthur C Clarke award in 2011? That Beukes accepted her award wearing a sloth? That is has more good reviews than you can shake a stick at?

I tend to feel that western urban fantasy just isn’t as fantastical, or even as urban, as I’d like. The cities don’t feel real, the fantasy is bland and forgettable, and there are only so many vampire/werewolf boyfriends I can take. Zoo City was, for me, the perfect antidote to that: properly gritty, and funny, with a brilliant main character and a city (Johannesburg) that feels like it exists beyond the confines of the novel. I can’t really give it any more endorsement, other than to say, go read it!

Spring 2012 Reading

As usual when I do these occasional book posts, I’m not going to go through every single thing I’ve read over the last six months. Instead, I just want to focus on the books and authors I’ve loved, in the hopes that others will discover their work for the first time and love them as much as I have. So, what’s on the list this time?

‘Tigana’ – Guy Gavriel Kay.     I’m going to start with my absolute favourite. It’s fair to say that I’ve read a good number of fantasy books, and that Tigana has got to be one of the most accomplished I’ve ever come across. It’s long, and complex, and beautifully written, and more subtle than the majority of books I’ve read in any genre. Kay’s characters are remarkably well-drawn, and the novel as a whole is heart-breaking half a dozen times over. If you can read Tigana and not cry at Dianora’s story at least once, then I’m fairly certain you’ve misplaced your heart.

‘The Kingdom of Gods’ and ‘The Killing Moon’ – N.K. Jemisin.     With these two books, Jemisin has ended one trilogy and started a duology (of which the second book is already available). I’d be lying if I said I loved the two equally – The Kingdom of Gods just edged ahead for me, due to already knowing the characters and having loved them through the two previous books. The Killing Moon is an excellent fantasy too, though, with an Egyptian-inspired setting, a brilliant magic system and Jemisin’s strong characterisation. I think I’ve said before that Jemisin is on my (very short) list of authors whose books I’ll buy no matter what they write – these two latest books have only confirmed that.

‘The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle’ – Haruki Murukami.     This is the first Murukami novel I read and so far my favourite (I also read Kafka on the Shore recently, but it didn’t really click with me). It’s a strange, meandering, surreal book, and no matter where it might get shelved in bookshops, it seems to me a sort of modern fantasy of the urban-but-having-nothing-to-do-with-vampires variety. Instead you get war stories and wig factories, a missing wife and, er… a bloke who spends a lot of time sitting in a well. It sounds incredibly dull, but there’s something about Murukami’s writing (in translation, of course) and the way he builds his plots that’s weirdly compelling.

‘Wither’ – Lauren DeStefano.     I don’t read a lot of YA fiction but Wither is an impressive debut from DeStefano and well worth a look. There’s more than a touch of The Handmaid’s Tale about it, with a cloistered world of husbands and multiple wives who don’t survive past their 20s. Some of the science might be a bit suspect, but this is a story about the characters most of all, with plenty of shades of grey in every personality, be they ostensibly hero or villain. I also thought it was wonderfully written, and I suspect DeStefano could be one to watch in coming years.

So, that’s what’s been taking up room on my bookshelves recently (and, ahem, being read when I should have been working). What about yours?

This Writing Life: Is Your Hero A Bully?

I’ve been reading a book recently (which I won’t name, because I want to use it as an example of a larger point, rather than an exercise in author bashing), which has got me thinking about anti-heroes, and more specifically how they relate to the characters around them.

You see, in this particular book – billed as a ‘romantic fantasy tale’, no less – the female main character and the male main character (who both have POV) really get off on the wrong foot when they meet. Stories of lovers who start off hating each other are nothing new, but this book goes a bit further. In their first confrontation, the hero and heroine get into something of a fight. He insults her, spits at her, even drags her around by the hair. At the end of the scene, he does offer to help her, but grudgingly, and only because he needs her help in return.

So, the wrong foot, as I said. The relationship continues in much the same vein. I kept expecting – hoping, really – that the female character would stand up for herself a little more: that she’d kick the hero’s arse, deliver a rousing speech, even just spit in his soup (she cooks for him on several occasions). Instead, she shows her defiance in coldness and a straight back. Given that she’s scared of him but trying not to show it, that’s perhaps fair enough.

The real problem, though, comes from the hero and his POV. Given that this is supposed to be a romance, he really is nothing more than a bully. He continually insults the female character and is aggressive towards her (which is supposedly because he ‘does everything passionately’, and because he’s had a hard life – ‘extenuating circumstances’, if you will). He is angered by her apparent defiance, and immensely pleased when he finds out she’s scared of him. And when his feelings towards her start to soften, as is inevitable? It’s not because he starts to understand the heroine, or believe that she’s not actually loathsome after all. Instead, he becomes attracted to her. He still hates her, is still aggressive towards her – but he’d also quite like to have sex with her.

Now, I’ll admit I haven’t finished the book, and there could be a massive reversal before the end (I have flicked ahead though, and they do end up together). Still, after reading two-thirds of the story, I can’t help but think of it as anything more than a catalogue of abuse. No matter how often the author tries to show the hero doing the right thing, he’s consistently vicious towards the female main character, making the idea that they’ll get married at the end not far from abhorrent.

I’m not, in the end, trying to say that you shouldn’t write unpleasant characters. There are plenty of brilliant anti-heroes out there, both male and female. If your character needs to be a bastard, to have done horrible things, to be almost as terrible as the villain – then write the character that way. But if you’re trying to build a romantic relationship between two characters, no matter how opposed they might seem in the beginning? Please, don’t make your hero a bully.

Choice and Emotion in Gaming and Books

Forgive me for the slightly unwieldy title on this one – it’s the only one I could come up with that didn’t seem completely melodramatic. Anyway, today I wanted to talk about something I’ve noticed recently in gaming and reading, and how they differ in affecting our emotions. This particular aspect, at least, all comes down to choice.

Let’s start with an example, and a fairly well known one. The Mass Effect games have been in the news recently for all the wrong reasons (namely, everyone hated the end of the latest installment), but it’s important not to forget how brilliant the first game was. And yet, despite that, I never managed to finish it. A single part of the game did it for me: a section which ended with the death of a character, and left me feeling so devastated that I could never find the heart to finish the game.

Plenty of games try to evoke emotion, just as books do. I know many people found the death of Aeris in Final Fantasy VII to be incredibly moving. For me though, it was a bit of a ‘meh’ moment, and the same goes for many books I’ve read. Thing is though, even when I do come across emotionally powerful books – and I’ve talked about a few recently – I only want to read them more. So what’s the difference?

I’ve realised that it all comes down to choice, and in this case, the personal choice of the reader or gamer. You see, in Mass Effect, which character met a sticky end was down to the player. Admittedly, there were only two characters to choose from, but forcing the player to pick one to live and one to die was incredibly powerful – and made me feel terrible afterwards. I actually changed my mind and replayed that section to save the other character, but it didn’t really help. I was devastated, and I lost all enthusiasm for the game.

The same thing simply can’t happen in a book. No matter what you want to happen, the plot and the ending are always set in stone, by the author rather than the reader (perhaps one reason why fan-fic is so popular – getting to rewrite those endings and ‘fix’ the bits you didn’t like). This lack of choice is actually something I like. There’s a feeling of being in the hands of a professional, of knowing that the story will end exactly as it should, and not be messed up by my own ineptitude as reader. There’s also the fact that choice can be frustrating as well as powerful: in that Mass Effect example, there was no option to attempt to save both characters, or neither – the player was forced to choose between them, a choice I would have preferred not to make.

So which is better? Should games avoid giving you a choice – or should they always give you a choice, to make the emotional impact more powerful? It’s down to the individual game, of course, just as whether that choice is appreciated or not is down to the individual player. It’s an aspect of gaming that, for good or ill, I think is going to become more prevalent as games become more sophisticated, allowing for more plotlines and possibilities. And if that choice becomes wearing, and I just want a good story? Well, I can always reach for a book.

This Writing Life: Drawn to the Fantastic

A few weeks ago I looked back over the list of books I’ve read recently and confirmed something I’d already suspected: nearly everything I’d read over as much as the past eighteen months has been fantasy, and particularly epic fantasy. I decided, as I do from time to time, that I was going to make an effort to read a bit more widely. With this resolution, I went to the library and took out a couple of books from the ‘general fiction’ section. It wasn’t until I got home that I realised I’d, inadvertantly, picked up books with a strong fantastical element: one is sort of magical realism, but definitely contains some weirdness. The other is about demons.

The same thing happens every time I make that same resolution. No matter whether I intend it or not, everything I read (or at least all the fiction) contains something a little bit out of the ordinary, be it a talking cat in an otherwise ‘literary’ novel, or a grand, sweeping epic fantasy set in a secondary world. Now, you could argue that most fiction contains at least a little bit of the strange and unusual, but my reading habits go beyond that. Either consciously or unconsciously, I am always drawn to the fantastic, to something beyond the everyday world, to magic and weirdness and speculation.

The same goes for my writing: everything I write has at least some tinge of the fantastic to it, no matter the setting. And that’t not because I want to be known as a ‘fantasy author’. It’s simply what I enjoy, what my mind turns to every time I come up with a story. Without that weird streak, fiction always seems to be a little bit… well, boring.

I think all writers are the same. No matter their genre, there are certain subjects, certain conceits or situations or characters, that they keep coming back to, again and again (and, in terms of style, certain ‘crutch’ words or phrases too, but that’s another post). For me it’s an element of the fantastic, but it’s also super-competent female characters, and vast landscapes, and bittersweet endings. And that’s only at the moment. Whilst some aspects (those competent female characters) have been common in my writing ever since I started, others come and go – I seem to alternate between setting novels in vast forests and vast cities, for example.

So, as a writer or an artist, what do you keep coming back to – what genres, settings, character-types or situations? Do you do it consciously, or not? And do you think there’s a value in identifying these recurring tropes – and in trying to do something different?

This Writing Life: Words Like A Punch to the Gut

The more I read, and specifically the more I analyse what I read, the more I’ve realised there are two general things that make me keep going back to an author’s books. The first is just basic enjoyment: I like their prose, their world-building, their plotting etc. etc. Usually, I can pin that down to one or two aspects. The second thing, though, is more complex and less tangible. In these authors’ works, it’s the emotional impact they create I keep going back for.

Here’s an example: I’ve just been reading Kate Elliott’s ‘Shadow Gate’ (I’m about two-thirds of the way through, in fact). I don’t want to go too far into spoiler territory, because this is the second book in a trilogy. There’s a character in the first two books, though, who has been brutalised and traumatised to the point that she no longer speaks, and seems to have lost the will to live. She remains incredibly passive for the entirety of the first book in the series, and the first half of the second, cropping up from time to time, but always being seen through the eyes of other characters, who view her as little more than an object to be used as they will.

And then, halfway through Shadow Gate, Elliott fully introduces this character for the first time. We see who she was before, what her life was like, and glimpses of the horrors that have turned her into who she is now. When I finally made the connection (which was probably supposed to be obvious from the start, but it took me a good dozen scenes to work it out) between the current, traumatised, passive character and the strong, capable girl she had been before, I think I probably winced. I was horrified, and astounded, and it felt a little bit like being punched in the gut.

It’s impossible for me to unpack everything Elliott does to achieve this reaction – it may even be that not everyone who reads these books will feel the same way I did. I’ve sometimes lent similar books to other people, only for them to come back with a ‘Meh’, whilst I stand there open-mouthed. How could they just not get it? But, of course, reading is incredibly subjective, etc. etc., and that’s not what I want to get into now.

Instead, I want to make a point about that all-important emotional impact. It’s this, more than anything else, that makes me return again and again to certain authors: when the characters and situations feel so real and compelling to me that their outcomes – which are often bad, but there are happy endings too – leave me physically exhausted, or utterly elated. There are only a handful of authors who I find can do this (again, we’re back to the subjectivity of reading), but when I find them, I love them forever.

It’s this sort of reaction that, as writers, we want to engender in readers. There must be a thousand ways to accomplish it, just as there are a thousand ways to read a book in which an author has tried to accomplish it. When, as readers, we find a book that has this impact on us though, I think it’s essential to sit down and think about why it worked, and how we can aim to emulate that success in our own work. Because having readers laugh and cry and sigh longingly over my fiction? THAT’S what I want to eventually achieve!

This Writing Life: Linear Narratives vs. Open Worlds, in Gaming and Fiction

There’s been a lot of gaming going on in our house recently (there usually is), which has got me thinking about RPGs and – of all things – narrative structure. Take two games that are both classed as RPGs but which are actually very different: at the moment I’m thinking of Final Fantasy XIII (or most JRPGs, for that matter) and Skyrim. Both set out to immerse you in a fantasy world, and feature a fair amount of customisation for your player characters, but that’s where the similarities end.

Let’s start with FF-XIII. I’m not going to go into the story – that’s irrelevent for this post. Suffice to say it has a story, and a very linear one at that. As you play through the game, you are forced along a single path, uncovering backstory, world details and character development as you go. For many gamers, being ‘railed’ (stuck to a single path within the game, with no player choices to be made) is something to grouse about. I, on the other hand, really like it. This is the form of gaming that, for me, most closely mimics the narrative structure of a novel. Whilst it’s not for everyone, the strictness of the structure does ensure that you really know the characters by the end of the game, and you’ve lived through a coherent story with a beginning, middle and end (as long as the writers/developers have done a decent job, of course).

Next we move onto Skyrim, which is entirely at the other end of the spectrum. Skyrim provides the player with an extremely open world. You could easily spend weeks playing the game without ever following the ‘main’ storyline. Your character develops entirely as you choose, and world-building comes from talking to NPCs or reading books within the game (woah, meta). Whilst this can be rewarding in its own way, it’s not something you could ever achieve in fiction, as far as I can see. A book with so little structure would just be unreadable – in fact, it would become essentially a piece of world-building and nothing else, particularly as Skyrim doesn’t go in for deep character development. I’m not sure it can, when there are so many hundreds of NPCs and your own character’s personality is built up from your responses and nothing else (you essentially have no history before you arrive in Skyrim, a trait which all of the Elder Scrolls games seem to follow).

What really got me thinking about this was the latest Final Fantasy game, XIII-2, which employs a system of jumping around between different time zones. Essentially, the player can experience the story in almost any order, although within each zone, the story and events are fixed. Does this map onto a style of fiction? I’m not sure. I considered the Choose Your Own Adventure books I talked about recently, but they provide a different ending for every read-through, whereas I think the end of Final Fantasy XIII-2 is fixed. Perhaps it’s closer to this sort of thing, in which the pages/scenes can be read in any order. Each re-reading of the book/play-through of the game will reveal new insight into the overall story, but the constituent parts remain the same.

This is not a blog post for which I can draw any sort of conclusions, because I don’t have an argument as such, and I’m not going to choose one structure as superior to the rest. All I would say is that there are all manner of sources out there from which writers can draw inspiration, including for their narrative structures. I know there are writers who will sniff at gaming, just as there are literary writers who disdain all ‘genre’ works. However, until you’ve sampled a little bit of everything, you can’t really know what you’re going to like – or what you can learn from.

A Bit of Fantasy Nostalgia

For some reason, my partner and I have talked about Choose Your Own Adventure books (and their equivalents from other publishers) several times recently. We both seem to have had just one of these books each, which we remember fondly: his was from the Fighting Fantasy line, and mine… Well, until yesterday I couldn’t quite remember what it was called. I knew it was about a circus, with characters called Petra and something like Lila. It also had a pegasus in it, and owl bears. In a fit of nostalgia, I decided to try to find it online. The result? THIS:

Now, isn’t that an amazing piece of sheer 80s-ness, if ever there was one. Props to this site for full details of the book, which turns out to have been called ‘Circus of Fear’. It was actually part of the Dungeons & Dragons world, although I’d never heard of D&D at the time, and I don’t think I ever noticed their name on the book.

Now, I’m not recommending anyone go out and find a copy of this book – it was probably pretty cheesy even by 80s fantasy standards. Still, I’m struck by just how much I remember about it. The pegasus, the character names (the girl was actually ‘Laela’, but I was close), the owl bears, the circus, and that teardrop on the front cover, which I believe was a crystallised pegasus tear owned by the main character. I’m not going to claim that this book gave me my love of fantasy, either (that was Tolkien), but it must have been somewhere in the mix. I certainly loved it when I was little.

Really, this is nothing but a bit of nostalgia, so if anyone would like to add their childhood favourites in the comments (bonus points for 80s fantasy!), please do. On another note, I managed to dredge up the full listings of this book, the name of which I couldn’t previously remember, in about ten minutes flat. Isn’t it amazing what you can find on the internet?

Goals for 2012

After looking back at 2011 over the last couple of posts, it’s time for me to look ahead. 2012 is before us, and now is the perfect time to make plans. These aren’t exactly resolutions, but more like goals – there are concrete steps I need to take to achieve them (and yes, I do have a lot of those steps mapped out, but I’m not going to go through them here). So, what are my goals?

  • Start submitting Sanguine. This is the novel I’ve been working on for several years now. The actual first draft only took a few months, but I’ve been editing it – on and off – ever since. I’ve now reached the point where I really can’t do any more, so my first priority is a final copy-edit to catch the last typos and infelicities, then sending it off to agents.
  • Finish Dust. This is the novel I started in the second half of 2011. I have about a third written, so I’m aiming to finish the last two-thirds by around June. Not much more to say about that: it’s a simple case of sitting down and hammering out the words. (Simple. Ha! That’s never simple, no matter how many times you’ve done it.)
  • Start… Something Else. Bit of a vague one, this. I have yet another novel in the planning stages, which is what I’ll probably work on once Dust is complete. Probably. Maybe. We’ll see.
  • Short stories. I always make goals regarding short stories – how many to write, how many to submit, how many of last year’s to edit – and I always fall flat on my face. I’m still planning to write more shorts this year, but this is the most nebulous of my goals. I’ll probably work on dozens, but I may well not finish a single one, and actually selling them is even less likely.
  • Reading. Actually, this might be my most nebulous goal: read more. More, more, more. I seem to have been reading even more slowly than usual this year. I usually aim for a book a week – which I was far behind in 2011 – so that will be 2012’s goal.

So, there are my goals for 2012, at least in reading and writing (I’m not counting the others, like learning to knit, and growing more veg, and doing more exercise). If you’ve got goals for the year ahead, feel free to share them in the comments. Sometimes, writing your goals – or resolutions, if your prefer – down is the first step to achieving them.

Reading in 2011

After looking back at my writing progress in my last post, I thought now would be a good time to share some of the interesting books I read during 2011 (and maybe some of the not-so-interesting ones too, if I’m feeling like a rant). Looking back through my reading list, two things immediately jump out at me: 1) I really didn’t read many books last year, and 2) those that I did read mostly don’t need mentioning. It’s not that they were particularly bad… but they weren’t particularly good either.

Having said that, I did read plenty of really good books too. I talked about a fair number of them here (in March), and here (in September). I’m not going to attempt to pick a favourite out of the seven books I mentioned in those posts – all were excellent, and deserve your attention, be they new books or classics. There are one or two excellent books I’ve so far neglected to mention, though, which are as follows:

‘The Broken Kingdoms’ – N.K. Jemisin        I’m amazed I haven’t already mentioned this book on the blog (I don’t think I have, anyway), because it was absolutely one of my favourite books of the year, as was the previous book in the series. If anything, ‘The Broken Kingdoms’ is possibly even better, expanding the world and the gods in fantastic new ways – and turning all my expectations from the first book completely on their head (there was one character in particular I thought would be impossible to like – until this book). And if you don’t sniffle even a little bit at the end, then you must have a heart of stone.

‘Retribution Falls’ – Chris Wooding        Airships! Fights! Action! A motley crew of strong characters with unfortunate pasts! I’ve been a fan of Wooding’s books for years, particularly the ‘Braided Path’ series, but if anything, ‘Retribution Falls’ is even better. If you like your fantasy fast-paced, action-packed and never boring, whilst still being able to believe in the characters, this is the book for you.

‘The Third God’ – Ricardo Pinto         The last book on my list took me a full six months to read, which doesn’t sound like an endorsement, but truly is. Pinto’s ‘Stone Dance of the Chameleon’ series has got to be one of the most intricate, fascinating and innovative fantasy trilogies in the last decade, and I’ve been waiting for the last book in the series ever since the second came out (in 2003, I believe). Why did it take me six months to read ‘The Third God’ then? Because it’s vast, and complex, and there were some parts so harrowing that I had to put the book down for weeks at a time. That probably still doesn’t sound like an endorsement, but fantasy so often takes the easy way out – Pinto doesn’t. (And if I still haven’t convinced you, the whole series is worth reading for Pinto’s magnificent writing alone.)

So, three more excellent books to round off the year. What great books did you read in 2011? Suggestions for great reads in 2012 are always appreciated!